When is a measured soil organic matter fraction equivalent to a model pool?

Joanne Ursula Smith, Peter Smith, R. Monaghan, R. J. Macdonald

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

77 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Dynamic simulation models are important tools for rationalizing complex changes in soil organic matter. Most such models for organic matter can be described as having either a pool structure or a continuous one. A pool structure can offer advantages in ease of use and transferability. Some pools are easily measured, whereas others cannot be measured directly. New methods of fractionation are being developed in an attempt to base models on measurable fractions. A requirement for such models is a demonstration that the measured fraction and model pool are equivalent. A measured fraction is equivalent to a model pool only if, within acceptable limits, it is unique as well as non-composite. If the measured fraction is not unique, describing it as a separate pool adds no extra information, while the added complexity can increase propagation of errors. If it is composite then the characteristics of the fraction will change with changing environment as a result of changing proportions of subpools. This will produce a model that cannot be applied without deriving parameters afresh: such a model is of greatly reduced value. Here we develop methods to examine if a fraction is both unique and non-composite. The tests for unique and composite pools were applied to the SUNDIAL (simulation of nitrogen dynamics in arable land) model of organic matter and nitrogen turnover in soil. Results suggest that the debris, biomass and humus pools are unique, but biomass and humus are composed of two or more subpools. This worked example illustrates how, given suitable data, any pool-based model can be tested by these methods.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)405-416
Number of pages11
JournalEuropean Journal of Soil Science
Volume53
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2002

Keywords

  • N-15-LABELED FERTILIZER
  • PHYSICAL SEPARATION
  • NITROGEN
  • CARBON
  • TURNOVER
  • DYNAMICS
  • WHEAT

Cite this

When is a measured soil organic matter fraction equivalent to a model pool? / Smith, Joanne Ursula; Smith, Peter; Monaghan, R.; Macdonald, R. J.

In: European Journal of Soil Science, Vol. 53, 2002, p. 405-416.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f938343dc1384c5b90333aef8b28427d,
title = "When is a measured soil organic matter fraction equivalent to a model pool?",
abstract = "Dynamic simulation models are important tools for rationalizing complex changes in soil organic matter. Most such models for organic matter can be described as having either a pool structure or a continuous one. A pool structure can offer advantages in ease of use and transferability. Some pools are easily measured, whereas others cannot be measured directly. New methods of fractionation are being developed in an attempt to base models on measurable fractions. A requirement for such models is a demonstration that the measured fraction and model pool are equivalent. A measured fraction is equivalent to a model pool only if, within acceptable limits, it is unique as well as non-composite. If the measured fraction is not unique, describing it as a separate pool adds no extra information, while the added complexity can increase propagation of errors. If it is composite then the characteristics of the fraction will change with changing environment as a result of changing proportions of subpools. This will produce a model that cannot be applied without deriving parameters afresh: such a model is of greatly reduced value. Here we develop methods to examine if a fraction is both unique and non-composite. The tests for unique and composite pools were applied to the SUNDIAL (simulation of nitrogen dynamics in arable land) model of organic matter and nitrogen turnover in soil. Results suggest that the debris, biomass and humus pools are unique, but biomass and humus are composed of two or more subpools. This worked example illustrates how, given suitable data, any pool-based model can be tested by these methods.",
keywords = "N-15-LABELED FERTILIZER, PHYSICAL SEPARATION, NITROGEN, CARBON, TURNOVER, DYNAMICS, WHEAT",
author = "Smith, {Joanne Ursula} and Peter Smith and R. Monaghan and Macdonald, {R. J.}",
year = "2002",
doi = "10.1046/j.1365-2389.2002.00458.x",
language = "English",
volume = "53",
pages = "405--416",
journal = "European Journal of Soil Science",
issn = "1351-0754",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - When is a measured soil organic matter fraction equivalent to a model pool?

AU - Smith, Joanne Ursula

AU - Smith, Peter

AU - Monaghan, R.

AU - Macdonald, R. J.

PY - 2002

Y1 - 2002

N2 - Dynamic simulation models are important tools for rationalizing complex changes in soil organic matter. Most such models for organic matter can be described as having either a pool structure or a continuous one. A pool structure can offer advantages in ease of use and transferability. Some pools are easily measured, whereas others cannot be measured directly. New methods of fractionation are being developed in an attempt to base models on measurable fractions. A requirement for such models is a demonstration that the measured fraction and model pool are equivalent. A measured fraction is equivalent to a model pool only if, within acceptable limits, it is unique as well as non-composite. If the measured fraction is not unique, describing it as a separate pool adds no extra information, while the added complexity can increase propagation of errors. If it is composite then the characteristics of the fraction will change with changing environment as a result of changing proportions of subpools. This will produce a model that cannot be applied without deriving parameters afresh: such a model is of greatly reduced value. Here we develop methods to examine if a fraction is both unique and non-composite. The tests for unique and composite pools were applied to the SUNDIAL (simulation of nitrogen dynamics in arable land) model of organic matter and nitrogen turnover in soil. Results suggest that the debris, biomass and humus pools are unique, but biomass and humus are composed of two or more subpools. This worked example illustrates how, given suitable data, any pool-based model can be tested by these methods.

AB - Dynamic simulation models are important tools for rationalizing complex changes in soil organic matter. Most such models for organic matter can be described as having either a pool structure or a continuous one. A pool structure can offer advantages in ease of use and transferability. Some pools are easily measured, whereas others cannot be measured directly. New methods of fractionation are being developed in an attempt to base models on measurable fractions. A requirement for such models is a demonstration that the measured fraction and model pool are equivalent. A measured fraction is equivalent to a model pool only if, within acceptable limits, it is unique as well as non-composite. If the measured fraction is not unique, describing it as a separate pool adds no extra information, while the added complexity can increase propagation of errors. If it is composite then the characteristics of the fraction will change with changing environment as a result of changing proportions of subpools. This will produce a model that cannot be applied without deriving parameters afresh: such a model is of greatly reduced value. Here we develop methods to examine if a fraction is both unique and non-composite. The tests for unique and composite pools were applied to the SUNDIAL (simulation of nitrogen dynamics in arable land) model of organic matter and nitrogen turnover in soil. Results suggest that the debris, biomass and humus pools are unique, but biomass and humus are composed of two or more subpools. This worked example illustrates how, given suitable data, any pool-based model can be tested by these methods.

KW - N-15-LABELED FERTILIZER

KW - PHYSICAL SEPARATION

KW - NITROGEN

KW - CARBON

KW - TURNOVER

KW - DYNAMICS

KW - WHEAT

U2 - 10.1046/j.1365-2389.2002.00458.x

DO - 10.1046/j.1365-2389.2002.00458.x

M3 - Article

VL - 53

SP - 405

EP - 416

JO - European Journal of Soil Science

JF - European Journal of Soil Science

SN - 1351-0754

ER -