When less of the same is more

Benefits of variability of practice in pianists

Marc Bangert, Anna Wiedemann, Hans-Christian Jabusch

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Variability of practice has been demonstrated to have beneficial effects for motor skill acquisition, transfer, and retention. This study extends the line of research to musical practice. Pianists were trained to perform a wide interval leap on the piano with their left hand. Performance at the target distance was tested before and after a 30-minute controlled training. One group (FIX) practiced the target interval only. The other group (VAR) received variable training on four different intervals including the target. Transfer was tested on an interval novel to either group. Retention was assessed in a retest 24 hours later. Leap Distance Error (LDE) and Leap Execution Time (LET) were measured. After training, LDE improved non-significantly in both groups. In the VAR group significant improvement was seen on the next day. This was not the case in the FIX group. In contrast to the FIX group, the VAR group showed significantly faster LET after training compared to baseline, which was stable at retention. The findings are discussed with regard to predictions made by theories of motor learning and implications for musical practice.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of the International Symposium on Performance Science 2013
EditorsAaron Williamon, Werner Goebl
Place of PublicationBrussels, Belgium
PublisherUtrecht: European Association of Conservatoires (AEC)
Pages117-122
Number of pages6
ISBN (Print)9782960137804
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Motor Skills
Hand
Learning
Research

Keywords

  • variability of practice
  • piano
  • motor skill acquisition
  • musicians
  • schema theory

Cite this

Bangert, M., Wiedemann, A., & Jabusch, H-C. (2013). When less of the same is more: Benefits of variability of practice in pianists. In A. Williamon, & W. Goebl (Eds.), Proceedings of the International Symposium on Performance Science 2013 (pp. 117-122). Brussels, Belgium: Utrecht: European Association of Conservatoires (AEC).

When less of the same is more : Benefits of variability of practice in pianists. / Bangert, Marc ; Wiedemann, Anna; Jabusch, Hans-Christian.

Proceedings of the International Symposium on Performance Science 2013. ed. / Aaron Williamon; Werner Goebl. Brussels, Belgium : Utrecht: European Association of Conservatoires (AEC), 2013. p. 117-122.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Bangert, M, Wiedemann, A & Jabusch, H-C 2013, When less of the same is more: Benefits of variability of practice in pianists. in A Williamon & W Goebl (eds), Proceedings of the International Symposium on Performance Science 2013. Utrecht: European Association of Conservatoires (AEC), Brussels, Belgium, pp. 117-122.
Bangert M, Wiedemann A, Jabusch H-C. When less of the same is more: Benefits of variability of practice in pianists. In Williamon A, Goebl W, editors, Proceedings of the International Symposium on Performance Science 2013. Brussels, Belgium: Utrecht: European Association of Conservatoires (AEC). 2013. p. 117-122
Bangert, Marc ; Wiedemann, Anna ; Jabusch, Hans-Christian. / When less of the same is more : Benefits of variability of practice in pianists. Proceedings of the International Symposium on Performance Science 2013. editor / Aaron Williamon ; Werner Goebl. Brussels, Belgium : Utrecht: European Association of Conservatoires (AEC), 2013. pp. 117-122
@inproceedings{50c2eb58ae8442508e97425e7973745f,
title = "When less of the same is more: Benefits of variability of practice in pianists",
abstract = "Variability of practice has been demonstrated to have beneficial effects for motor skill acquisition, transfer, and retention. This study extends the line of research to musical practice. Pianists were trained to perform a wide interval leap on the piano with their left hand. Performance at the target distance was tested before and after a 30-minute controlled training. One group (FIX) practiced the target interval only. The other group (VAR) received variable training on four different intervals including the target. Transfer was tested on an interval novel to either group. Retention was assessed in a retest 24 hours later. Leap Distance Error (LDE) and Leap Execution Time (LET) were measured. After training, LDE improved non-significantly in both groups. In the VAR group significant improvement was seen on the next day. This was not the case in the FIX group. In contrast to the FIX group, the VAR group showed significantly faster LET after training compared to baseline, which was stable at retention. The findings are discussed with regard to predictions made by theories of motor learning and implications for musical practice.",
keywords = "variability of practice, piano, motor skill acquisition, musicians, schema theory",
author = "Marc Bangert and Anna Wiedemann and Hans-Christian Jabusch",
note = "Acknowledgments The authors wish to thank Sebastian Peter Zippel for his contributions to data collection, Christoph Lehmann for discussion of statistical issues, and the IMM seminar class on systematic musicology (summer 2012) for inspiring discussions.",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
isbn = "9782960137804",
pages = "117--122",
editor = "Aaron Williamon and Werner Goebl",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the International Symposium on Performance Science 2013",
publisher = "Utrecht: European Association of Conservatoires (AEC)",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - When less of the same is more

T2 - Benefits of variability of practice in pianists

AU - Bangert, Marc

AU - Wiedemann, Anna

AU - Jabusch, Hans-Christian

N1 - Acknowledgments The authors wish to thank Sebastian Peter Zippel for his contributions to data collection, Christoph Lehmann for discussion of statistical issues, and the IMM seminar class on systematic musicology (summer 2012) for inspiring discussions.

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Variability of practice has been demonstrated to have beneficial effects for motor skill acquisition, transfer, and retention. This study extends the line of research to musical practice. Pianists were trained to perform a wide interval leap on the piano with their left hand. Performance at the target distance was tested before and after a 30-minute controlled training. One group (FIX) practiced the target interval only. The other group (VAR) received variable training on four different intervals including the target. Transfer was tested on an interval novel to either group. Retention was assessed in a retest 24 hours later. Leap Distance Error (LDE) and Leap Execution Time (LET) were measured. After training, LDE improved non-significantly in both groups. In the VAR group significant improvement was seen on the next day. This was not the case in the FIX group. In contrast to the FIX group, the VAR group showed significantly faster LET after training compared to baseline, which was stable at retention. The findings are discussed with regard to predictions made by theories of motor learning and implications for musical practice.

AB - Variability of practice has been demonstrated to have beneficial effects for motor skill acquisition, transfer, and retention. This study extends the line of research to musical practice. Pianists were trained to perform a wide interval leap on the piano with their left hand. Performance at the target distance was tested before and after a 30-minute controlled training. One group (FIX) practiced the target interval only. The other group (VAR) received variable training on four different intervals including the target. Transfer was tested on an interval novel to either group. Retention was assessed in a retest 24 hours later. Leap Distance Error (LDE) and Leap Execution Time (LET) were measured. After training, LDE improved non-significantly in both groups. In the VAR group significant improvement was seen on the next day. This was not the case in the FIX group. In contrast to the FIX group, the VAR group showed significantly faster LET after training compared to baseline, which was stable at retention. The findings are discussed with regard to predictions made by theories of motor learning and implications for musical practice.

KW - variability of practice

KW - piano

KW - motor skill acquisition

KW - musicians

KW - schema theory

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 9782960137804

SP - 117

EP - 122

BT - Proceedings of the International Symposium on Performance Science 2013

A2 - Williamon, Aaron

A2 - Goebl, Werner

PB - Utrecht: European Association of Conservatoires (AEC)

CY - Brussels, Belgium

ER -