Wire tension in the Ilizarov system: accuracy of the wire-tensioning device

M A Watson, K J Mathias, G P Ashcroft, N Maffulli, D W L Hukins, D E T Shepherd

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The Ilizarov fixator consists of tensioned wires that attach bone segments to a modular frame. The aim of this study was to establish the accuracy and precision of the wire-tensioning device supplied with the Ilizarov external fixation system. The device was used to tension a wire in direct opposition to a calibrated load cell. Five subjects tested three devices, at each of their four tension settings, in two separate sessions. Subjects could not see the true tension during the test. There were significant differences between the results for different subjects (p < 0.01) and instruments (p < 0.01) but not for different tension settings or between the two sessions. Overall mean measured tensions were 4.9 per cent (standard deviation, 4.4 per cent) below intended values. Tensions obtained at the maximum edge (completely occluded) on the scale markings were significantly (p < 0.001) closer to the nominal values (mean discrepancy, 3.6 per cent) than those at the minimum edge (mean discrepancy, 17.6 per cent). Several factors influence wire tension. Tensioning devices are not identical and the results obtained with them depend on the user. If the scale markings are completely occluded, the discrepancy between intended and actual tensions of around 5 per cent is likely to be adequate for clinical practice since surgeons do not select the most suitable tension following quantitative data assessment, but rather it is a judgement based on surgical experience and consideration for the patient weight and expected level of activity.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)355-359
Number of pages5
JournalProceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers. Part H, Journal of Engineering in Medicine
Volume219
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2005

Keywords

  • external fixation
  • Ilizarov
  • tensioning device
  • wire tension
  • EXTERNAL FIXATORS
  • MECHANICAL PERFORMANCE
  • TIBIAL FRACTURES
  • WEIGHT-BEARING
  • FIXATION
  • STIFFNESS

Cite this

Wire tension in the Ilizarov system: accuracy of the wire-tensioning device. / Watson, M A ; Mathias, K J ; Ashcroft, G P ; Maffulli, N ; Hukins, D W L ; Shepherd, D E T .

In: Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers. Part H, Journal of Engineering in Medicine, Vol. 219, 2005, p. 355-359.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f3000f4a24b64adcbd02d4ca6ed3ea33,
title = "Wire tension in the Ilizarov system: accuracy of the wire-tensioning device",
abstract = "The Ilizarov fixator consists of tensioned wires that attach bone segments to a modular frame. The aim of this study was to establish the accuracy and precision of the wire-tensioning device supplied with the Ilizarov external fixation system. The device was used to tension a wire in direct opposition to a calibrated load cell. Five subjects tested three devices, at each of their four tension settings, in two separate sessions. Subjects could not see the true tension during the test. There were significant differences between the results for different subjects (p < 0.01) and instruments (p < 0.01) but not for different tension settings or between the two sessions. Overall mean measured tensions were 4.9 per cent (standard deviation, 4.4 per cent) below intended values. Tensions obtained at the maximum edge (completely occluded) on the scale markings were significantly (p < 0.001) closer to the nominal values (mean discrepancy, 3.6 per cent) than those at the minimum edge (mean discrepancy, 17.6 per cent). Several factors influence wire tension. Tensioning devices are not identical and the results obtained with them depend on the user. If the scale markings are completely occluded, the discrepancy between intended and actual tensions of around 5 per cent is likely to be adequate for clinical practice since surgeons do not select the most suitable tension following quantitative data assessment, but rather it is a judgement based on surgical experience and consideration for the patient weight and expected level of activity.",
keywords = "external fixation, Ilizarov, tensioning device, wire tension, EXTERNAL FIXATORS, MECHANICAL PERFORMANCE, TIBIAL FRACTURES, WEIGHT-BEARING, FIXATION, STIFFNESS",
author = "Watson, {M A} and Mathias, {K J} and Ashcroft, {G P} and N Maffulli and Hukins, {D W L} and Shepherd, {D E T}",
year = "2005",
doi = "10.1243/095441105X34310",
language = "English",
volume = "219",
pages = "355--359",
journal = "Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers. Part H, Journal of Engineering in Medicine",
issn = "0954-4119",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Wire tension in the Ilizarov system: accuracy of the wire-tensioning device

AU - Watson, M A

AU - Mathias, K J

AU - Ashcroft, G P

AU - Maffulli, N

AU - Hukins, D W L

AU - Shepherd, D E T

PY - 2005

Y1 - 2005

N2 - The Ilizarov fixator consists of tensioned wires that attach bone segments to a modular frame. The aim of this study was to establish the accuracy and precision of the wire-tensioning device supplied with the Ilizarov external fixation system. The device was used to tension a wire in direct opposition to a calibrated load cell. Five subjects tested three devices, at each of their four tension settings, in two separate sessions. Subjects could not see the true tension during the test. There were significant differences between the results for different subjects (p < 0.01) and instruments (p < 0.01) but not for different tension settings or between the two sessions. Overall mean measured tensions were 4.9 per cent (standard deviation, 4.4 per cent) below intended values. Tensions obtained at the maximum edge (completely occluded) on the scale markings were significantly (p < 0.001) closer to the nominal values (mean discrepancy, 3.6 per cent) than those at the minimum edge (mean discrepancy, 17.6 per cent). Several factors influence wire tension. Tensioning devices are not identical and the results obtained with them depend on the user. If the scale markings are completely occluded, the discrepancy between intended and actual tensions of around 5 per cent is likely to be adequate for clinical practice since surgeons do not select the most suitable tension following quantitative data assessment, but rather it is a judgement based on surgical experience and consideration for the patient weight and expected level of activity.

AB - The Ilizarov fixator consists of tensioned wires that attach bone segments to a modular frame. The aim of this study was to establish the accuracy and precision of the wire-tensioning device supplied with the Ilizarov external fixation system. The device was used to tension a wire in direct opposition to a calibrated load cell. Five subjects tested three devices, at each of their four tension settings, in two separate sessions. Subjects could not see the true tension during the test. There were significant differences between the results for different subjects (p < 0.01) and instruments (p < 0.01) but not for different tension settings or between the two sessions. Overall mean measured tensions were 4.9 per cent (standard deviation, 4.4 per cent) below intended values. Tensions obtained at the maximum edge (completely occluded) on the scale markings were significantly (p < 0.001) closer to the nominal values (mean discrepancy, 3.6 per cent) than those at the minimum edge (mean discrepancy, 17.6 per cent). Several factors influence wire tension. Tensioning devices are not identical and the results obtained with them depend on the user. If the scale markings are completely occluded, the discrepancy between intended and actual tensions of around 5 per cent is likely to be adequate for clinical practice since surgeons do not select the most suitable tension following quantitative data assessment, but rather it is a judgement based on surgical experience and consideration for the patient weight and expected level of activity.

KW - external fixation

KW - Ilizarov

KW - tensioning device

KW - wire tension

KW - EXTERNAL FIXATORS

KW - MECHANICAL PERFORMANCE

KW - TIBIAL FRACTURES

KW - WEIGHT-BEARING

KW - FIXATION

KW - STIFFNESS

U2 - 10.1243/095441105X34310

DO - 10.1243/095441105X34310

M3 - Article

VL - 219

SP - 355

EP - 359

JO - Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers. Part H, Journal of Engineering in Medicine

JF - Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers. Part H, Journal of Engineering in Medicine

SN - 0954-4119

ER -