A critical review of the impacts of cover crops on nitrogen leaching, net greenhouse gas balance and crop productivity

Mohamed Abdalla (Corresponding Author), Astley Hastings, Kun Cheng, Qian Yue, Dave Chadwick, Mikk Espenberg, Jaak Truu, Robert M. Rees, Pete Smith (Corresponding Author)

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Cover crops play an increasingly important role in improving soil quality, reducing agricultural inputs and improving environmental sustainability. The main objectives of this critical global review and systematic analysis were to assess cover crop practices in the context of their impacts on nitrogen leaching, net greenhouse gas balances (NGHGB) and crop productivity. Only studies that investigated the impacts of cover crops and measured one or a combination of: nitrogen leaching, soil organic carbon (SOC), nitrous oxide (N2O), grain yield and nitrogen in grain of primary crop, and had a control treatment were included in the analysis. Long-term studies were uncommon, with most data coming from studies lasting 2-3 years. The literature search resulted in 106 studies carried out at 372 sites and covering different countries, climatic zones and management. Our analysis demonstrates that cover crops significantly (p<0.001) decreased N leaching and significantly (p<0.001) increased SOC sequestration without having significant (p>0.05) effects on direct N2O emissions. Cover crops could mitigate the NGHGB by 2.06 ±2.10 Mg CO2-eq ha-1 y-1. One of the potential disadvantages of cover crops identified was the reduction in grain yield of the primary crop by ≈4%, compared to the control treatment. This drawback could be avoided by selecting mixed cover crops with a range of legumes and non-legumes, which increased the yield by ≈13%. These advantages of cover crops justify their widespread adoption. However, management practices in relation to cover crops will need to be adapted to specific soil, management and regional climatic conditions.
Original languageEnglish
JournalGlobal Change Biology
Early online date13 May 2019
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 13 May 2019

Fingerprint

cover crop
Greenhouse gases
Leaching
Crops
greenhouse gas
Nitrogen
Productivity
leaching
productivity
crop
nitrogen
Soils
soil management
soil quality
nitrous oxide
management practice
Nitrous Oxide
Organic carbon
organic carbon
sustainability

Keywords

  • Cover crop
  • Catch crop
  • N leaching
  • Soil organic carbon
  • N in grain
  • Nitrous oxide emissions
  • net greenhouse gas balance
  • green manure
  • yield
  • N content
  • nitrate
  • C sequestration

Cite this

A critical review of the impacts of cover crops on nitrogen leaching, net greenhouse gas balance and crop productivity. / Abdalla, Mohamed (Corresponding Author); Hastings, Astley; Cheng, Kun; Yue, Qian; Chadwick, Dave; Espenberg, Mikk; Truu, Jaak; Rees, Robert M.; Smith, Pete (Corresponding Author).

In: Global Change Biology, 13.05.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{0b17c8ab72df4758aca1d37f91da131b,
title = "A critical review of the impacts of cover crops on nitrogen leaching, net greenhouse gas balance and crop productivity",
abstract = "Cover crops play an increasingly important role in improving soil quality, reducing agricultural inputs and improving environmental sustainability. The main objectives of this critical global review and systematic analysis were to assess cover crop practices in the context of their impacts on nitrogen leaching, net greenhouse gas balances (NGHGB) and crop productivity. Only studies that investigated the impacts of cover crops and measured one or a combination of: nitrogen leaching, soil organic carbon (SOC), nitrous oxide (N2O), grain yield and nitrogen in grain of primary crop, and had a control treatment were included in the analysis. Long-term studies were uncommon, with most data coming from studies lasting 2-3 years. The literature search resulted in 106 studies carried out at 372 sites and covering different countries, climatic zones and management. Our analysis demonstrates that cover crops significantly (p<0.001) decreased N leaching and significantly (p<0.001) increased SOC sequestration without having significant (p>0.05) effects on direct N2O emissions. Cover crops could mitigate the NGHGB by 2.06 ±2.10 Mg CO2-eq ha-1 y-1. One of the potential disadvantages of cover crops identified was the reduction in grain yield of the primary crop by ≈4{\%}, compared to the control treatment. This drawback could be avoided by selecting mixed cover crops with a range of legumes and non-legumes, which increased the yield by ≈13{\%}. These advantages of cover crops justify their widespread adoption. However, management practices in relation to cover crops will need to be adapted to specific soil, management and regional climatic conditions.",
keywords = "Cover crop, Catch crop, N leaching, Soil organic carbon, N in grain, Nitrous oxide emissions, net greenhouse gas balance, green manure, yield, N content, nitrate, C sequestration",
author = "Mohamed Abdalla and Astley Hastings and Kun Cheng and Qian Yue and Dave Chadwick and Mikk Espenberg and Jaak Truu and Rees, {Robert M.} and Pete Smith",
note = "This work contributes to the UK-China Virtual Joint Centre N-Circle (grant number BB/N013484/1), SuperG (funded under EU Horizon 2020 programme) and ADVENT (grant number NE/M019691/1). DRC was supported by the UK-China Virtual joint Centre for Agricultural Nitrogen (CINAg, BB/N013468/1) and the UK-Brazil Virtual Joint Centre to deliver enhanced N-use efficiency via an integrated soil-plant systems approach (NUCLEUS), which are jointly supported by Newton fund via UK BBSRC and NERC. Jaak Truu received financing from Estonian Research Council (grant PRG548).",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
day = "13",
doi = "10.1111/gcb.14644",
language = "English",
journal = "Global Change Biology",
issn = "1354-1013",
publisher = "John Wiley & Sons, Ltd (10.1111)",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A critical review of the impacts of cover crops on nitrogen leaching, net greenhouse gas balance and crop productivity

AU - Abdalla, Mohamed

AU - Hastings, Astley

AU - Cheng, Kun

AU - Yue, Qian

AU - Chadwick, Dave

AU - Espenberg, Mikk

AU - Truu, Jaak

AU - Rees, Robert M.

AU - Smith, Pete

N1 - This work contributes to the UK-China Virtual Joint Centre N-Circle (grant number BB/N013484/1), SuperG (funded under EU Horizon 2020 programme) and ADVENT (grant number NE/M019691/1). DRC was supported by the UK-China Virtual joint Centre for Agricultural Nitrogen (CINAg, BB/N013468/1) and the UK-Brazil Virtual Joint Centre to deliver enhanced N-use efficiency via an integrated soil-plant systems approach (NUCLEUS), which are jointly supported by Newton fund via UK BBSRC and NERC. Jaak Truu received financing from Estonian Research Council (grant PRG548).

PY - 2019/5/13

Y1 - 2019/5/13

N2 - Cover crops play an increasingly important role in improving soil quality, reducing agricultural inputs and improving environmental sustainability. The main objectives of this critical global review and systematic analysis were to assess cover crop practices in the context of their impacts on nitrogen leaching, net greenhouse gas balances (NGHGB) and crop productivity. Only studies that investigated the impacts of cover crops and measured one or a combination of: nitrogen leaching, soil organic carbon (SOC), nitrous oxide (N2O), grain yield and nitrogen in grain of primary crop, and had a control treatment were included in the analysis. Long-term studies were uncommon, with most data coming from studies lasting 2-3 years. The literature search resulted in 106 studies carried out at 372 sites and covering different countries, climatic zones and management. Our analysis demonstrates that cover crops significantly (p<0.001) decreased N leaching and significantly (p<0.001) increased SOC sequestration without having significant (p>0.05) effects on direct N2O emissions. Cover crops could mitigate the NGHGB by 2.06 ±2.10 Mg CO2-eq ha-1 y-1. One of the potential disadvantages of cover crops identified was the reduction in grain yield of the primary crop by ≈4%, compared to the control treatment. This drawback could be avoided by selecting mixed cover crops with a range of legumes and non-legumes, which increased the yield by ≈13%. These advantages of cover crops justify their widespread adoption. However, management practices in relation to cover crops will need to be adapted to specific soil, management and regional climatic conditions.

AB - Cover crops play an increasingly important role in improving soil quality, reducing agricultural inputs and improving environmental sustainability. The main objectives of this critical global review and systematic analysis were to assess cover crop practices in the context of their impacts on nitrogen leaching, net greenhouse gas balances (NGHGB) and crop productivity. Only studies that investigated the impacts of cover crops and measured one or a combination of: nitrogen leaching, soil organic carbon (SOC), nitrous oxide (N2O), grain yield and nitrogen in grain of primary crop, and had a control treatment were included in the analysis. Long-term studies were uncommon, with most data coming from studies lasting 2-3 years. The literature search resulted in 106 studies carried out at 372 sites and covering different countries, climatic zones and management. Our analysis demonstrates that cover crops significantly (p<0.001) decreased N leaching and significantly (p<0.001) increased SOC sequestration without having significant (p>0.05) effects on direct N2O emissions. Cover crops could mitigate the NGHGB by 2.06 ±2.10 Mg CO2-eq ha-1 y-1. One of the potential disadvantages of cover crops identified was the reduction in grain yield of the primary crop by ≈4%, compared to the control treatment. This drawback could be avoided by selecting mixed cover crops with a range of legumes and non-legumes, which increased the yield by ≈13%. These advantages of cover crops justify their widespread adoption. However, management practices in relation to cover crops will need to be adapted to specific soil, management and regional climatic conditions.

KW - Cover crop

KW - Catch crop

KW - N leaching

KW - Soil organic carbon

KW - N in grain

KW - Nitrous oxide emissions

KW - net greenhouse gas balance

KW - green manure

KW - yield

KW - N content

KW - nitrate

KW - C sequestration

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/critical-review-impacts-cover-crops-nitrogen-leaching-net-greenhouse-gas-balance-crop-productivity

U2 - 10.1111/gcb.14644

DO - 10.1111/gcb.14644

M3 - Article

JO - Global Change Biology

JF - Global Change Biology

SN - 1354-1013

ER -