A general framework for estimating multidimensional contingency fit

Simon C Parker, Arjen van Witteloostuijn

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

18 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper develops a framework for estimating multidimensional fit. In the context of contingency thinking and the resource-based view of the firm, there is a clear need for quantitative approaches that integrate fit-as-deviation, fit-as-moderation, and fit-as-system perspectives, implying that the impact on organizational performance of series of bivariate (mis)fits and bundles of multiple (mis)fits are estimated in an integrated fashion. Our approach offers opportunities to do precisely this. Moreover, we suggest summary statistics that can be applied to test for the (non)significance of fit linkages at both the disaggregated level of individual bivariate interactions, as well as the aggregated level of groups of multivariate interactions. We systematically compare our approach with extant alternatives using simulations, including the fit-as-mediation alternative. We find that our approach outperforms these established alternatives by including fit-as-moderation and fit-as-deviation as special cases, by being better able to capture the nature of the underlying fit structure in the data and by being relatively robust to mismeasurements, small sample sizes, and collinearity. We conclude by discussing our method's advantages and disadvantages.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)540-553
Number of pages14
JournalOrganization Science
Volume21
Issue number2
Early online date28 Jul 2009
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2010

Fingerprint

Statistics
Contingency
Interaction
Moderation
Deviation
Small sample
Sample size
Resource-based view of the firm
Collinearity
Integrated
Linkage
Disadvantage
Mediation
Organizational performance
Simulation
Systems perspective

Keywords

  • contingency theory
  • multidimensional fit
  • organizational performance

Cite this

A general framework for estimating multidimensional contingency fit. / Parker, Simon C; van Witteloostuijn, Arjen.

In: Organization Science, Vol. 21, No. 2, 03.2010, p. 540-553.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Parker, Simon C ; van Witteloostuijn, Arjen. / A general framework for estimating multidimensional contingency fit. In: Organization Science. 2010 ; Vol. 21, No. 2. pp. 540-553.
@article{53b6fcd079714867adced429f1aca3b5,
title = "A general framework for estimating multidimensional contingency fit",
abstract = "This paper develops a framework for estimating multidimensional fit. In the context of contingency thinking and the resource-based view of the firm, there is a clear need for quantitative approaches that integrate fit-as-deviation, fit-as-moderation, and fit-as-system perspectives, implying that the impact on organizational performance of series of bivariate (mis)fits and bundles of multiple (mis)fits are estimated in an integrated fashion. Our approach offers opportunities to do precisely this. Moreover, we suggest summary statistics that can be applied to test for the (non)significance of fit linkages at both the disaggregated level of individual bivariate interactions, as well as the aggregated level of groups of multivariate interactions. We systematically compare our approach with extant alternatives using simulations, including the fit-as-mediation alternative. We find that our approach outperforms these established alternatives by including fit-as-moderation and fit-as-deviation as special cases, by being better able to capture the nature of the underlying fit structure in the data and by being relatively robust to mismeasurements, small sample sizes, and collinearity. We conclude by discussing our method's advantages and disadvantages.",
keywords = "contingency theory, multidimensional fit, organizational performance",
author = "Parker, {Simon C} and {van Witteloostuijn}, Arjen",
year = "2010",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1287/orsc.1090.0464",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "540--553",
journal = "Organization Science",
issn = "1047-7039",
publisher = "INFORMS Inst.for Operations Res.and the Management Sciences",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A general framework for estimating multidimensional contingency fit

AU - Parker, Simon C

AU - van Witteloostuijn, Arjen

PY - 2010/3

Y1 - 2010/3

N2 - This paper develops a framework for estimating multidimensional fit. In the context of contingency thinking and the resource-based view of the firm, there is a clear need for quantitative approaches that integrate fit-as-deviation, fit-as-moderation, and fit-as-system perspectives, implying that the impact on organizational performance of series of bivariate (mis)fits and bundles of multiple (mis)fits are estimated in an integrated fashion. Our approach offers opportunities to do precisely this. Moreover, we suggest summary statistics that can be applied to test for the (non)significance of fit linkages at both the disaggregated level of individual bivariate interactions, as well as the aggregated level of groups of multivariate interactions. We systematically compare our approach with extant alternatives using simulations, including the fit-as-mediation alternative. We find that our approach outperforms these established alternatives by including fit-as-moderation and fit-as-deviation as special cases, by being better able to capture the nature of the underlying fit structure in the data and by being relatively robust to mismeasurements, small sample sizes, and collinearity. We conclude by discussing our method's advantages and disadvantages.

AB - This paper develops a framework for estimating multidimensional fit. In the context of contingency thinking and the resource-based view of the firm, there is a clear need for quantitative approaches that integrate fit-as-deviation, fit-as-moderation, and fit-as-system perspectives, implying that the impact on organizational performance of series of bivariate (mis)fits and bundles of multiple (mis)fits are estimated in an integrated fashion. Our approach offers opportunities to do precisely this. Moreover, we suggest summary statistics that can be applied to test for the (non)significance of fit linkages at both the disaggregated level of individual bivariate interactions, as well as the aggregated level of groups of multivariate interactions. We systematically compare our approach with extant alternatives using simulations, including the fit-as-mediation alternative. We find that our approach outperforms these established alternatives by including fit-as-moderation and fit-as-deviation as special cases, by being better able to capture the nature of the underlying fit structure in the data and by being relatively robust to mismeasurements, small sample sizes, and collinearity. We conclude by discussing our method's advantages and disadvantages.

KW - contingency theory

KW - multidimensional fit

KW - organizational performance

U2 - 10.1287/orsc.1090.0464

DO - 10.1287/orsc.1090.0464

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 540

EP - 553

JO - Organization Science

JF - Organization Science

SN - 1047-7039

IS - 2

ER -