Anthropology contra ethnography

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)
18 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Ethnography aims to describe life as it is lived and experienced, by a people, somewhere, sometime. Anthropology, by contrast, is an inquiry into the conditions and possibilities of human life in the world. Anthropology and ethnography may have much to contribute to one another, but their aims and objectives are different. Ethnography is an end in itself; it is not a means to anthropological ends. Moreover, participant observation is an anthropological way of working, not a method of ethnographic data collection. To study anthropology is to study with people, not to make studies of them; such study is not so much ethnographic as educational. An anthropological education gives us the intellectual means to speculate on the conditions of human life in this world, without our having to pretend that our arguments are distillations of the practical wisdom of those among whom we have worked. Our job is to correspond with them, not to speak for them. Only by acknowledging the speculative nature of anthropological inquiry can we both make our voices heard and properly engage with other disciplines. And only then can we lead the way in forging the universities of the future.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)21-26
Number of pages6
JournalHau: Journal of Ethnographic Theory
Volume7
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Fingerprint

ethnography
anthropology
participant observation
wisdom
university
education

Keywords

  • ethnography
  • anthropology
  • participation
  • observation
  • method
  • education
  • philosophy
  • art
  • university

Cite this

Anthropology contra ethnography. / Ingold, Timothy.

In: Hau: Journal of Ethnographic Theory, Vol. 7, No. 1, 2017, p. 21-26.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{970cd04c1b0543a39ff5fbf507e487d8,
title = "Anthropology contra ethnography",
abstract = "Ethnography aims to describe life as it is lived and experienced, by a people, somewhere, sometime. Anthropology, by contrast, is an inquiry into the conditions and possibilities of human life in the world. Anthropology and ethnography may have much to contribute to one another, but their aims and objectives are different. Ethnography is an end in itself; it is not a means to anthropological ends. Moreover, participant observation is an anthropological way of working, not a method of ethnographic data collection. To study anthropology is to study with people, not to make studies of them; such study is not so much ethnographic as educational. An anthropological education gives us the intellectual means to speculate on the conditions of human life in this world, without our having to pretend that our arguments are distillations of the practical wisdom of those among whom we have worked. Our job is to correspond with them, not to speak for them. Only by acknowledging the speculative nature of anthropological inquiry can we both make our voices heard and properly engage with other disciplines. And only then can we lead the way in forging the universities of the future.",
keywords = "ethnography, anthropology, participation, observation, method, education, philosophy, art, university",
author = "Timothy Ingold",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.14318/hau7.1.005",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "21--26",
journal = "Hau: Journal of Ethnographic Theory",
issn = "2049-1115",
publisher = "HAU Society for Ethnographic Theory",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Anthropology contra ethnography

AU - Ingold, Timothy

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - Ethnography aims to describe life as it is lived and experienced, by a people, somewhere, sometime. Anthropology, by contrast, is an inquiry into the conditions and possibilities of human life in the world. Anthropology and ethnography may have much to contribute to one another, but their aims and objectives are different. Ethnography is an end in itself; it is not a means to anthropological ends. Moreover, participant observation is an anthropological way of working, not a method of ethnographic data collection. To study anthropology is to study with people, not to make studies of them; such study is not so much ethnographic as educational. An anthropological education gives us the intellectual means to speculate on the conditions of human life in this world, without our having to pretend that our arguments are distillations of the practical wisdom of those among whom we have worked. Our job is to correspond with them, not to speak for them. Only by acknowledging the speculative nature of anthropological inquiry can we both make our voices heard and properly engage with other disciplines. And only then can we lead the way in forging the universities of the future.

AB - Ethnography aims to describe life as it is lived and experienced, by a people, somewhere, sometime. Anthropology, by contrast, is an inquiry into the conditions and possibilities of human life in the world. Anthropology and ethnography may have much to contribute to one another, but their aims and objectives are different. Ethnography is an end in itself; it is not a means to anthropological ends. Moreover, participant observation is an anthropological way of working, not a method of ethnographic data collection. To study anthropology is to study with people, not to make studies of them; such study is not so much ethnographic as educational. An anthropological education gives us the intellectual means to speculate on the conditions of human life in this world, without our having to pretend that our arguments are distillations of the practical wisdom of those among whom we have worked. Our job is to correspond with them, not to speak for them. Only by acknowledging the speculative nature of anthropological inquiry can we both make our voices heard and properly engage with other disciplines. And only then can we lead the way in forging the universities of the future.

KW - ethnography

KW - anthropology

KW - participation

KW - observation

KW - method

KW - education

KW - philosophy

KW - art

KW - university

U2 - 10.14318/hau7.1.005

DO - 10.14318/hau7.1.005

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 21

EP - 26

JO - Hau: Journal of Ethnographic Theory

JF - Hau: Journal of Ethnographic Theory

SN - 2049-1115

IS - 1

ER -