Definitions of severe and difficult asthma by a group of UK general practitioners

Mandy Moffat, Jennifer Anne Cleland, Thys Van Der Molen, David Brendan Price

Research output: Contribution to journalAbstract

Abstract

Aims:
This qualitative study explores how general practitioners (GPs) in the United Kingdom perceive “severe” and “difficult” asthma.

Methods:
13 GPs were interviewed using grounded theory method, the interviews were recorded, transcribed and analysed for themes pertaining to severe and difficult asthma.

Results:
GPs conceptualised ‘severe’ asthma and ‘difficult’ asthma in different ways. ‘Severe’ asthma was understood in more medical terms where ‘difficult’ asthma tended to be asthma that was difficult to get under control due to a variety of reasons including social and psychological patient variables. Perceived patient barriers fell into five main categories; knowledge (e.g., lack of understanding of medication and/or disease), identity, coping, health behaviours (e.g., smoking) and other, non-disease, factors such as chaotic lifestyle. Two GPs expressed difficulty using the term ‘difficult’ asthma due to the excessive numbers of terms being used in asthma and the pejorative nature or this term.

Conclusions:
The different conceptions found in this study confirm that there is no one agreed definition for “severe” or “difficult” asthma. However, most interviewees defined “difficult” asthma using a broader, biopsychosocial definition than that applied to severe asthma. This research is part of an ongoing study investigating healthcare professionals' experiences of, and attitudes towards, managing severe and difficult asthma.
Original languageEnglish
Article number67
JournalPrimary Care Respiratory Journal
Early online date1 Jun 2002
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2002

Fingerprint

General Practitioners
Asthma
Psychological Adaptation
Health Behavior
Life Style
Smoking
Interviews
Psychology
Delivery of Health Care

Cite this

@article{a658ad57bb75470e84f85f2c2b3b040b,
title = "Definitions of severe and difficult asthma by a group of UK general practitioners",
abstract = "Aims:This qualitative study explores how general practitioners (GPs) in the United Kingdom perceive “severe” and “difficult” asthma.Methods:13 GPs were interviewed using grounded theory method, the interviews were recorded, transcribed and analysed for themes pertaining to severe and difficult asthma.Results:GPs conceptualised ‘severe’ asthma and ‘difficult’ asthma in different ways. ‘Severe’ asthma was understood in more medical terms where ‘difficult’ asthma tended to be asthma that was difficult to get under control due to a variety of reasons including social and psychological patient variables. Perceived patient barriers fell into five main categories; knowledge (e.g., lack of understanding of medication and/or disease), identity, coping, health behaviours (e.g., smoking) and other, non-disease, factors such as chaotic lifestyle. Two GPs expressed difficulty using the term ‘difficult’ asthma due to the excessive numbers of terms being used in asthma and the pejorative nature or this term.Conclusions:The different conceptions found in this study confirm that there is no one agreed definition for “severe” or “difficult” asthma. However, most interviewees defined “difficult” asthma using a broader, biopsychosocial definition than that applied to severe asthma. This research is part of an ongoing study investigating healthcare professionals' experiences of, and attitudes towards, managing severe and difficult asthma.",
author = "Mandy Moffat and Cleland, {Jennifer Anne} and {Van Der Molen}, Thys and Price, {David Brendan}",
year = "2002",
doi = "10.1038/pcrj.2002.54",
language = "English",
journal = "Primary Care Respiratory Journal",
issn = "1471-4418",
publisher = "Primary Care Respiratory Society UK",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Definitions of severe and difficult asthma by a group of UK general practitioners

AU - Moffat, Mandy

AU - Cleland, Jennifer Anne

AU - Van Der Molen, Thys

AU - Price, David Brendan

PY - 2002

Y1 - 2002

N2 - Aims:This qualitative study explores how general practitioners (GPs) in the United Kingdom perceive “severe” and “difficult” asthma.Methods:13 GPs were interviewed using grounded theory method, the interviews were recorded, transcribed and analysed for themes pertaining to severe and difficult asthma.Results:GPs conceptualised ‘severe’ asthma and ‘difficult’ asthma in different ways. ‘Severe’ asthma was understood in more medical terms where ‘difficult’ asthma tended to be asthma that was difficult to get under control due to a variety of reasons including social and psychological patient variables. Perceived patient barriers fell into five main categories; knowledge (e.g., lack of understanding of medication and/or disease), identity, coping, health behaviours (e.g., smoking) and other, non-disease, factors such as chaotic lifestyle. Two GPs expressed difficulty using the term ‘difficult’ asthma due to the excessive numbers of terms being used in asthma and the pejorative nature or this term.Conclusions:The different conceptions found in this study confirm that there is no one agreed definition for “severe” or “difficult” asthma. However, most interviewees defined “difficult” asthma using a broader, biopsychosocial definition than that applied to severe asthma. This research is part of an ongoing study investigating healthcare professionals' experiences of, and attitudes towards, managing severe and difficult asthma.

AB - Aims:This qualitative study explores how general practitioners (GPs) in the United Kingdom perceive “severe” and “difficult” asthma.Methods:13 GPs were interviewed using grounded theory method, the interviews were recorded, transcribed and analysed for themes pertaining to severe and difficult asthma.Results:GPs conceptualised ‘severe’ asthma and ‘difficult’ asthma in different ways. ‘Severe’ asthma was understood in more medical terms where ‘difficult’ asthma tended to be asthma that was difficult to get under control due to a variety of reasons including social and psychological patient variables. Perceived patient barriers fell into five main categories; knowledge (e.g., lack of understanding of medication and/or disease), identity, coping, health behaviours (e.g., smoking) and other, non-disease, factors such as chaotic lifestyle. Two GPs expressed difficulty using the term ‘difficult’ asthma due to the excessive numbers of terms being used in asthma and the pejorative nature or this term.Conclusions:The different conceptions found in this study confirm that there is no one agreed definition for “severe” or “difficult” asthma. However, most interviewees defined “difficult” asthma using a broader, biopsychosocial definition than that applied to severe asthma. This research is part of an ongoing study investigating healthcare professionals' experiences of, and attitudes towards, managing severe and difficult asthma.

U2 - 10.1038/pcrj.2002.54

DO - 10.1038/pcrj.2002.54

M3 - Abstract

JO - Primary Care Respiratory Journal

JF - Primary Care Respiratory Journal

SN - 1471-4418

M1 - 67

ER -