Designing a new design PhD?

Emma Murphy, Naomi Jacobs

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

The higher education sector in the UK is currently undergoing rapid change,
and design education is no exception. Higher fee levels, limited grants and
self-funding PhD study is becoming more common. Furthermore, there is
increased demand for non-traditional modes of study such as part-time
provision and flexible learning – especially relevant to designer-practitioners.
A greater number of mature students are also entering higher education,
many of whom will have significant industry experience. But the design
student dynamic isn’t the only change we are seeing – the remit of design
academics is changing too. There is now an increased emphasis on the
economic and social benefits that academia can contribute, and the ‘impact
agenda’ requires research councils (and therefore academic researchers) to
show that their work has a wider societal impact in order to sustain funding.
Furthermore, design is an ever expanding and changing interdiscipline, and so
the make up and shape of the Design PhD is frequently in question.
But what do all these changes mean for doctoral design education? Is the
traditional PhD model still fit for purpose, or are we changing this beyond
recognition to accommodate design? Do we need a new Design PhD? In this
paper, we examine approaches in both mainstream design research training
(adaptations of the traditional model) and more novel PhD programmes,
which could form the grounding for curriculum design experts to further
question and develop the notion of the new Design PhD.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of the 19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference
Subtitle of host publicationDesign Management in an Era of Disruption
EditorsErik Bohemia, Alison Rieple, Jeanne Liedtka, Rachel Cooper
PublisherDesign Management Institute
Pages3063-3079
Number of pages17
ISBN (Print)9780615991528
Publication statusPublished - 12 Sep 2014
Event19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference: Design Management in an Era of Disruption - London, United Kingdom
Duration: 2 Sep 20144 Sep 2014

Conference

Conference19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityLondon
Period2/09/144/09/14

Fingerprint

Education
Electric grounding
Curricula
Students
Industry

Keywords

  • design education
  • doctoral education
  • Design PhD
  • research
  • curriculum
  • agile
  • hybrid academics
  • industry

Cite this

Murphy, E., & Jacobs, N. (2014). Designing a new design PhD? In E. Bohemia, A. Rieple, J. Liedtka, & R. Cooper (Eds.), Proceedings of the 19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference: Design Management in an Era of Disruption (pp. 3063-3079). Design Management Institute.

Designing a new design PhD? / Murphy, Emma; Jacobs, Naomi.

Proceedings of the 19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference: Design Management in an Era of Disruption. ed. / Erik Bohemia; Alison Rieple; Jeanne Liedtka; Rachel Cooper. Design Management Institute, 2014. p. 3063-3079.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Murphy, E & Jacobs, N 2014, Designing a new design PhD? in E Bohemia, A Rieple, J Liedtka & R Cooper (eds), Proceedings of the 19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference: Design Management in an Era of Disruption. Design Management Institute, pp. 3063-3079, 19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference, London, United Kingdom, 2/09/14.
Murphy E, Jacobs N. Designing a new design PhD? In Bohemia E, Rieple A, Liedtka J, Cooper R, editors, Proceedings of the 19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference: Design Management in an Era of Disruption. Design Management Institute. 2014. p. 3063-3079
Murphy, Emma ; Jacobs, Naomi. / Designing a new design PhD?. Proceedings of the 19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference: Design Management in an Era of Disruption. editor / Erik Bohemia ; Alison Rieple ; Jeanne Liedtka ; Rachel Cooper. Design Management Institute, 2014. pp. 3063-3079
@inproceedings{1b836bf17a6b4d36b1126f1024910928,
title = "Designing a new design PhD?",
abstract = "The higher education sector in the UK is currently undergoing rapid change,and design education is no exception. Higher fee levels, limited grants andself-funding PhD study is becoming more common. Furthermore, there isincreased demand for non-traditional modes of study such as part-timeprovision and flexible learning – especially relevant to designer-practitioners.A greater number of mature students are also entering higher education,many of whom will have significant industry experience. But the designstudent dynamic isn’t the only change we are seeing – the remit of designacademics is changing too. There is now an increased emphasis on theeconomic and social benefits that academia can contribute, and the ‘impactagenda’ requires research councils (and therefore academic researchers) toshow that their work has a wider societal impact in order to sustain funding.Furthermore, design is an ever expanding and changing interdiscipline, and sothe make up and shape of the Design PhD is frequently in question.But what do all these changes mean for doctoral design education? Is thetraditional PhD model still fit for purpose, or are we changing this beyondrecognition to accommodate design? Do we need a new Design PhD? In thispaper, we examine approaches in both mainstream design research training(adaptations of the traditional model) and more novel PhD programmes,which could form the grounding for curriculum design experts to furtherquestion and develop the notion of the new Design PhD.",
keywords = "design education, doctoral education, Design PhD, research, curriculum, agile, hybrid academics, industry",
author = "Emma Murphy and Naomi Jacobs",
note = "The Authors would like to thank the AHRC and EPSRC for their support in our programmes, and the students of Highwire and the Creative Exchange for their enthusiasm and participation.",
year = "2014",
month = "9",
day = "12",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780615991528",
pages = "3063--3079",
editor = "Erik Bohemia and Alison Rieple and Jeanne Liedtka and Rachel Cooper",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the 19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference",
publisher = "Design Management Institute",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Designing a new design PhD?

AU - Murphy, Emma

AU - Jacobs, Naomi

N1 - The Authors would like to thank the AHRC and EPSRC for their support in our programmes, and the students of Highwire and the Creative Exchange for their enthusiasm and participation.

PY - 2014/9/12

Y1 - 2014/9/12

N2 - The higher education sector in the UK is currently undergoing rapid change,and design education is no exception. Higher fee levels, limited grants andself-funding PhD study is becoming more common. Furthermore, there isincreased demand for non-traditional modes of study such as part-timeprovision and flexible learning – especially relevant to designer-practitioners.A greater number of mature students are also entering higher education,many of whom will have significant industry experience. But the designstudent dynamic isn’t the only change we are seeing – the remit of designacademics is changing too. There is now an increased emphasis on theeconomic and social benefits that academia can contribute, and the ‘impactagenda’ requires research councils (and therefore academic researchers) toshow that their work has a wider societal impact in order to sustain funding.Furthermore, design is an ever expanding and changing interdiscipline, and sothe make up and shape of the Design PhD is frequently in question.But what do all these changes mean for doctoral design education? Is thetraditional PhD model still fit for purpose, or are we changing this beyondrecognition to accommodate design? Do we need a new Design PhD? In thispaper, we examine approaches in both mainstream design research training(adaptations of the traditional model) and more novel PhD programmes,which could form the grounding for curriculum design experts to furtherquestion and develop the notion of the new Design PhD.

AB - The higher education sector in the UK is currently undergoing rapid change,and design education is no exception. Higher fee levels, limited grants andself-funding PhD study is becoming more common. Furthermore, there isincreased demand for non-traditional modes of study such as part-timeprovision and flexible learning – especially relevant to designer-practitioners.A greater number of mature students are also entering higher education,many of whom will have significant industry experience. But the designstudent dynamic isn’t the only change we are seeing – the remit of designacademics is changing too. There is now an increased emphasis on theeconomic and social benefits that academia can contribute, and the ‘impactagenda’ requires research councils (and therefore academic researchers) toshow that their work has a wider societal impact in order to sustain funding.Furthermore, design is an ever expanding and changing interdiscipline, and sothe make up and shape of the Design PhD is frequently in question.But what do all these changes mean for doctoral design education? Is thetraditional PhD model still fit for purpose, or are we changing this beyondrecognition to accommodate design? Do we need a new Design PhD? In thispaper, we examine approaches in both mainstream design research training(adaptations of the traditional model) and more novel PhD programmes,which could form the grounding for curriculum design experts to furtherquestion and develop the notion of the new Design PhD.

KW - design education

KW - doctoral education

KW - Design PhD

KW - research

KW - curriculum

KW - agile

KW - hybrid academics

KW - industry

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 9780615991528

SP - 3063

EP - 3079

BT - Proceedings of the 19th DMI: Academic Design Management Conference

A2 - Bohemia, Erik

A2 - Rieple, Alison

A2 - Liedtka, Jeanne

A2 - Cooper, Rachel

PB - Design Management Institute

ER -