Education and service: how theories can help in understanding tensions

Jennifer Cleland, Steven J Durning (Corresponding Author)

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: This paper reviews why tensions between service and education persist and highlights that this is an area of medical education research (MER) that, to date, lacks a robust body of theory-driven research. After carrying out a review of the literature on service-education tensions in medical education and training, we turn to consider how theory can help provide new insights into service-education tensions.

METHODS: We conducted a search of the literature on service-education tensions since 1998 to examine the use of theory in studies on this topic.

RESULTS: We identified 44 out of 603 relevant papers. Their focus fell into four broad categories: time residents spent on 'service' and 'education'; perceptions of the balance between service and education; considerations of how best to define service and education, and the impact of structural and systems changes on education/training. Of the papers reporting primary research, the dominant methodology was the bespoke survey. Rarely were the precise natures of tensions or how different factors interact to cause tensions examined in detail.

DISCUSSION: Through discussion and reflection, we then agreed on the applicability of four sociocultural theories for illuminating some examples of service-education tensions. We present four sociocultural theories: Holland's figured worlds, Kemmis et al.'s practice architectures, Lave and Wenger's situated learning and Engeström's cultural-historical activity theory (CHAT or AT). We describe each and then briefly illustrate how each theory can support new ways of thinking and potential directions for research focusing on education-service tensions.

CONCLUSIONS: The use of theory in research studies will not resolve service-education tensions. However, what theory can do is illuminate and magnify different aspects of service-education tensions, to generate new insight and knowledge that can then be used to inform future research and changes in practice.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)42-55
Number of pages14
JournalMedical Education
Volume53
Issue number1
Early online date24 Oct 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 Jan 2019

Fingerprint

education
system change
structural change
resident
cause
lack
methodology
learning
literature

Keywords

  • MEDICAL-EDUCATION
  • FIGURED WORLDS
  • SIMULATION
  • COMMUNITIES
  • WORK
  • RESIDENTS
  • FRAMEWORK
  • IDENTITY
  • STUDENTS
  • QUESTION

Cite this

Education and service : how theories can help in understanding tensions. / Cleland, Jennifer; Durning, Steven J (Corresponding Author).

In: Medical Education, Vol. 53, No. 1, 31.01.2019, p. 42-55.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Cleland, Jennifer ; Durning, Steven J. / Education and service : how theories can help in understanding tensions. In: Medical Education. 2019 ; Vol. 53, No. 1. pp. 42-55.
@article{23ec7d380afc4fb4ae2ea18ac1b201a5,
title = "Education and service: how theories can help in understanding tensions",
abstract = "OBJECTIVES: This paper reviews why tensions between service and education persist and highlights that this is an area of medical education research (MER) that, to date, lacks a robust body of theory-driven research. After carrying out a review of the literature on service-education tensions in medical education and training, we turn to consider how theory can help provide new insights into service-education tensions.METHODS: We conducted a search of the literature on service-education tensions since 1998 to examine the use of theory in studies on this topic.RESULTS: We identified 44 out of 603 relevant papers. Their focus fell into four broad categories: time residents spent on 'service' and 'education'; perceptions of the balance between service and education; considerations of how best to define service and education, and the impact of structural and systems changes on education/training. Of the papers reporting primary research, the dominant methodology was the bespoke survey. Rarely were the precise natures of tensions or how different factors interact to cause tensions examined in detail.DISCUSSION: Through discussion and reflection, we then agreed on the applicability of four sociocultural theories for illuminating some examples of service-education tensions. We present four sociocultural theories: Holland's figured worlds, Kemmis et al.'s practice architectures, Lave and Wenger's situated learning and Engestr{\"o}m's cultural-historical activity theory (CHAT or AT). We describe each and then briefly illustrate how each theory can support new ways of thinking and potential directions for research focusing on education-service tensions.CONCLUSIONS: The use of theory in research studies will not resolve service-education tensions. However, what theory can do is illuminate and magnify different aspects of service-education tensions, to generate new insight and knowledge that can then be used to inform future research and changes in practice.",
keywords = "MEDICAL-EDUCATION, FIGURED WORLDS, SIMULATION, COMMUNITIES, WORK, RESIDENTS, FRAMEWORK, IDENTITY, STUDENTS, QUESTION",
author = "Jennifer Cleland and Durning, {Steven J}",
note = "{\circledC} 2018 John Wiley & Sons Ltd and The Association for the Study of Medical Education.",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1111/medu.13738",
language = "English",
volume = "53",
pages = "42--55",
journal = "Medical Education",
issn = "0308-0110",
publisher = "WILEY-BLACKWELL",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Education and service

T2 - how theories can help in understanding tensions

AU - Cleland, Jennifer

AU - Durning, Steven J

N1 - © 2018 John Wiley & Sons Ltd and The Association for the Study of Medical Education.

PY - 2019/1/31

Y1 - 2019/1/31

N2 - OBJECTIVES: This paper reviews why tensions between service and education persist and highlights that this is an area of medical education research (MER) that, to date, lacks a robust body of theory-driven research. After carrying out a review of the literature on service-education tensions in medical education and training, we turn to consider how theory can help provide new insights into service-education tensions.METHODS: We conducted a search of the literature on service-education tensions since 1998 to examine the use of theory in studies on this topic.RESULTS: We identified 44 out of 603 relevant papers. Their focus fell into four broad categories: time residents spent on 'service' and 'education'; perceptions of the balance between service and education; considerations of how best to define service and education, and the impact of structural and systems changes on education/training. Of the papers reporting primary research, the dominant methodology was the bespoke survey. Rarely were the precise natures of tensions or how different factors interact to cause tensions examined in detail.DISCUSSION: Through discussion and reflection, we then agreed on the applicability of four sociocultural theories for illuminating some examples of service-education tensions. We present four sociocultural theories: Holland's figured worlds, Kemmis et al.'s practice architectures, Lave and Wenger's situated learning and Engeström's cultural-historical activity theory (CHAT or AT). We describe each and then briefly illustrate how each theory can support new ways of thinking and potential directions for research focusing on education-service tensions.CONCLUSIONS: The use of theory in research studies will not resolve service-education tensions. However, what theory can do is illuminate and magnify different aspects of service-education tensions, to generate new insight and knowledge that can then be used to inform future research and changes in practice.

AB - OBJECTIVES: This paper reviews why tensions between service and education persist and highlights that this is an area of medical education research (MER) that, to date, lacks a robust body of theory-driven research. After carrying out a review of the literature on service-education tensions in medical education and training, we turn to consider how theory can help provide new insights into service-education tensions.METHODS: We conducted a search of the literature on service-education tensions since 1998 to examine the use of theory in studies on this topic.RESULTS: We identified 44 out of 603 relevant papers. Their focus fell into four broad categories: time residents spent on 'service' and 'education'; perceptions of the balance between service and education; considerations of how best to define service and education, and the impact of structural and systems changes on education/training. Of the papers reporting primary research, the dominant methodology was the bespoke survey. Rarely were the precise natures of tensions or how different factors interact to cause tensions examined in detail.DISCUSSION: Through discussion and reflection, we then agreed on the applicability of four sociocultural theories for illuminating some examples of service-education tensions. We present four sociocultural theories: Holland's figured worlds, Kemmis et al.'s practice architectures, Lave and Wenger's situated learning and Engeström's cultural-historical activity theory (CHAT or AT). We describe each and then briefly illustrate how each theory can support new ways of thinking and potential directions for research focusing on education-service tensions.CONCLUSIONS: The use of theory in research studies will not resolve service-education tensions. However, what theory can do is illuminate and magnify different aspects of service-education tensions, to generate new insight and knowledge that can then be used to inform future research and changes in practice.

KW - MEDICAL-EDUCATION

KW - FIGURED WORLDS

KW - SIMULATION

KW - COMMUNITIES

KW - WORK

KW - RESIDENTS

KW - FRAMEWORK

KW - IDENTITY

KW - STUDENTS

KW - QUESTION

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/education-service-theories-help-understanding-tensions

U2 - 10.1111/medu.13738

DO - 10.1111/medu.13738

M3 - Article

C2 - 30357894

VL - 53

SP - 42

EP - 55

JO - Medical Education

JF - Medical Education

SN - 0308-0110

IS - 1

ER -