Exploratory Study of Comparison Income and Individual Debt Using British Household Panel Survey

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The famous saying “keeping up with the Joneses” is a generational behaviour that is still deeply interwoven in the behavioural fabric of our modern-day society. This paper aims to address and contribute to the existing literature by investigating the determinants of individual nonmortgage debt, focusing on the role of comparison income. It also seeks to overcome certain empirical shortcomings by applying Tobit, fixed effects, and Tobit fixed effects regression
models to a UK dataset. The study is motivated by previous research, which suggested the aspiration of borrowers is influential in the debt-decision process. Previous studies did not use empirical methods or UK data, however. Comparison income (the measure of the borrowers’ aspiration) is derived from the Mincer earnings equation. Tobit regression is applied in the cross-section analysis and is pertinent considering the censored nature of the dependent
variable. In the panel analysis, fixed effects and Tobit fixed effects are used to control for unobserved attributes of sampled individuals that may affect demand for debt. Comparison income and non-mortgage debt as well as other economic and demographic variables are positively and significantly associated. The relationship between comparison income and nonmortgage debt suggests the latter may be incurred for status-maintenance purposes.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)181-202
Number of pages21
JournalReview of Economic Analysis
Volume10
Issue number1
Early online date17 Apr 2018
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

Exploratory study
Debt
Comparison income
British Household Panel Survey
Fixed effects
Tobit
Aspiration
Economic variables
Decision process
Panel analysis
Cross section
Demographic variables
Tobit regression
Empirical methods

Keywords

  • non-mortgage debt
  • comparison income
  • status maintenance
  • consumer behaviour
  • Tobit
  • fixed effects
  • panel data

Cite this

Exploratory Study of Comparison Income and Individual Debt Using British Household Panel Survey. / Ejebu, Ourega.

In: Review of Economic Analysis, Vol. 10, No. 1, 2018, p. 181-202.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{75157d79e10f47aeaa84cecec24840ee,
title = "Exploratory Study of Comparison Income and Individual Debt Using British Household Panel Survey",
abstract = "The famous saying “keeping up with the Joneses” is a generational behaviour that is still deeply interwoven in the behavioural fabric of our modern-day society. This paper aims to address and contribute to the existing literature by investigating the determinants of individual nonmortgage debt, focusing on the role of comparison income. It also seeks to overcome certain empirical shortcomings by applying Tobit, fixed effects, and Tobit fixed effects regressionmodels to a UK dataset. The study is motivated by previous research, which suggested the aspiration of borrowers is influential in the debt-decision process. Previous studies did not use empirical methods or UK data, however. Comparison income (the measure of the borrowers’ aspiration) is derived from the Mincer earnings equation. Tobit regression is applied in the cross-section analysis and is pertinent considering the censored nature of the dependentvariable. In the panel analysis, fixed effects and Tobit fixed effects are used to control for unobserved attributes of sampled individuals that may affect demand for debt. Comparison income and non-mortgage debt as well as other economic and demographic variables are positively and significantly associated. The relationship between comparison income and nonmortgage debt suggests the latter may be incurred for status-maintenance purposes.",
keywords = "non-mortgage debt, comparison income, status maintenance, consumer behaviour, Tobit, fixed effects, panel data",
author = "Ourega Ejebu",
note = "This research was carried out in collaboration with the financial and scientific support group from the College of Art and Social Sciences (CASS) at the University of Aberdeen (Scotland). The comments and suggestions from Professor Ioannis Theodossiou and two anonymous referees from the Review of Economic Analysis were very useful to improving the content of this paper.",
year = "2018",
language = "English",
volume = "10",
pages = "181--202",
journal = "Review of Economic Analysis",
issn = "1973-3909",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Exploratory Study of Comparison Income and Individual Debt Using British Household Panel Survey

AU - Ejebu, Ourega

N1 - This research was carried out in collaboration with the financial and scientific support group from the College of Art and Social Sciences (CASS) at the University of Aberdeen (Scotland). The comments and suggestions from Professor Ioannis Theodossiou and two anonymous referees from the Review of Economic Analysis were very useful to improving the content of this paper.

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - The famous saying “keeping up with the Joneses” is a generational behaviour that is still deeply interwoven in the behavioural fabric of our modern-day society. This paper aims to address and contribute to the existing literature by investigating the determinants of individual nonmortgage debt, focusing on the role of comparison income. It also seeks to overcome certain empirical shortcomings by applying Tobit, fixed effects, and Tobit fixed effects regressionmodels to a UK dataset. The study is motivated by previous research, which suggested the aspiration of borrowers is influential in the debt-decision process. Previous studies did not use empirical methods or UK data, however. Comparison income (the measure of the borrowers’ aspiration) is derived from the Mincer earnings equation. Tobit regression is applied in the cross-section analysis and is pertinent considering the censored nature of the dependentvariable. In the panel analysis, fixed effects and Tobit fixed effects are used to control for unobserved attributes of sampled individuals that may affect demand for debt. Comparison income and non-mortgage debt as well as other economic and demographic variables are positively and significantly associated. The relationship between comparison income and nonmortgage debt suggests the latter may be incurred for status-maintenance purposes.

AB - The famous saying “keeping up with the Joneses” is a generational behaviour that is still deeply interwoven in the behavioural fabric of our modern-day society. This paper aims to address and contribute to the existing literature by investigating the determinants of individual nonmortgage debt, focusing on the role of comparison income. It also seeks to overcome certain empirical shortcomings by applying Tobit, fixed effects, and Tobit fixed effects regressionmodels to a UK dataset. The study is motivated by previous research, which suggested the aspiration of borrowers is influential in the debt-decision process. Previous studies did not use empirical methods or UK data, however. Comparison income (the measure of the borrowers’ aspiration) is derived from the Mincer earnings equation. Tobit regression is applied in the cross-section analysis and is pertinent considering the censored nature of the dependentvariable. In the panel analysis, fixed effects and Tobit fixed effects are used to control for unobserved attributes of sampled individuals that may affect demand for debt. Comparison income and non-mortgage debt as well as other economic and demographic variables are positively and significantly associated. The relationship between comparison income and nonmortgage debt suggests the latter may be incurred for status-maintenance purposes.

KW - non-mortgage debt

KW - comparison income

KW - status maintenance

KW - consumer behaviour

KW - Tobit

KW - fixed effects

KW - panel data

M3 - Article

VL - 10

SP - 181

EP - 202

JO - Review of Economic Analysis

JF - Review of Economic Analysis

SN - 1973-3909

IS - 1

ER -