Factors influencing accuracy of estimation of comprehension problems in patients following CVA, by doctors, nurses and relatives

Rpshan McClenahan, Marie Johnston, Yvonne Densham

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Previous work has shown that doctors, nurses and relatives are inaccurate at estimating the comprehension problem of stroke patients. Possible factors that influence the accuracy of these judgements were studied, including confidence of the respondents, the severity of the comprehension problems of the patients and factors specific to relatives (educational background and the length of the relative's relationship with the patient). Doctors, nurses and relatives involved with 30 recently aphasic stroke patients were asked to estimate how patients would perform on the comprehension sections of two tests (Western Aphasia Battery and Functional Communication Profile). Results show that although all respondents over-estimated patients' comprehension abilities, they were more accurate for patients who had mild problems. Doctors and nurses who were more confident about their predictions tended to be more accurate on some parts of the tests than those with less confidence, whereas relatives were equally inaccurate when giving high and low confidence judgements. Length of relationship and educational level did not predict relative's accuracy.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)209-219
Number of pages11
JournalEuropean Journal of Disorders of Communication
Volume27
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 1992

Fingerprint

Nurses
Stroke
Aptitude
Neuropsychological Tests
Aphasia
Communication
Surveys and Questionnaires

Keywords

  • aphasia
  • cerebrovascular accident

Cite this

Factors influencing accuracy of estimation of comprehension problems in patients following CVA, by doctors, nurses and relatives. / McClenahan, Rpshan; Johnston, Marie; Densham, Yvonne.

In: European Journal of Disorders of Communication, Vol. 27, No. 3, 07.1992, p. 209-219.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{daf6861f65ca4f2d85fdb984f4ece9a4,
title = "Factors influencing accuracy of estimation of comprehension problems in patients following CVA, by doctors, nurses and relatives",
abstract = "Previous work has shown that doctors, nurses and relatives are inaccurate at estimating the comprehension problem of stroke patients. Possible factors that influence the accuracy of these judgements were studied, including confidence of the respondents, the severity of the comprehension problems of the patients and factors specific to relatives (educational background and the length of the relative's relationship with the patient). Doctors, nurses and relatives involved with 30 recently aphasic stroke patients were asked to estimate how patients would perform on the comprehension sections of two tests (Western Aphasia Battery and Functional Communication Profile). Results show that although all respondents over-estimated patients' comprehension abilities, they were more accurate for patients who had mild problems. Doctors and nurses who were more confident about their predictions tended to be more accurate on some parts of the tests than those with less confidence, whereas relatives were equally inaccurate when giving high and low confidence judgements. Length of relationship and educational level did not predict relative's accuracy.",
keywords = "aphasia, cerebrovascular accident",
author = "Rpshan McClenahan and Marie Johnston and Yvonne Densham",
year = "1992",
month = "7",
doi = "10.3109/13682829209029421",
language = "English",
volume = "27",
pages = "209--219",
journal = "European Journal of Disorders of Communication",
issn = "0963-7273",
publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Factors influencing accuracy of estimation of comprehension problems in patients following CVA, by doctors, nurses and relatives

AU - McClenahan, Rpshan

AU - Johnston, Marie

AU - Densham, Yvonne

PY - 1992/7

Y1 - 1992/7

N2 - Previous work has shown that doctors, nurses and relatives are inaccurate at estimating the comprehension problem of stroke patients. Possible factors that influence the accuracy of these judgements were studied, including confidence of the respondents, the severity of the comprehension problems of the patients and factors specific to relatives (educational background and the length of the relative's relationship with the patient). Doctors, nurses and relatives involved with 30 recently aphasic stroke patients were asked to estimate how patients would perform on the comprehension sections of two tests (Western Aphasia Battery and Functional Communication Profile). Results show that although all respondents over-estimated patients' comprehension abilities, they were more accurate for patients who had mild problems. Doctors and nurses who were more confident about their predictions tended to be more accurate on some parts of the tests than those with less confidence, whereas relatives were equally inaccurate when giving high and low confidence judgements. Length of relationship and educational level did not predict relative's accuracy.

AB - Previous work has shown that doctors, nurses and relatives are inaccurate at estimating the comprehension problem of stroke patients. Possible factors that influence the accuracy of these judgements were studied, including confidence of the respondents, the severity of the comprehension problems of the patients and factors specific to relatives (educational background and the length of the relative's relationship with the patient). Doctors, nurses and relatives involved with 30 recently aphasic stroke patients were asked to estimate how patients would perform on the comprehension sections of two tests (Western Aphasia Battery and Functional Communication Profile). Results show that although all respondents over-estimated patients' comprehension abilities, they were more accurate for patients who had mild problems. Doctors and nurses who were more confident about their predictions tended to be more accurate on some parts of the tests than those with less confidence, whereas relatives were equally inaccurate when giving high and low confidence judgements. Length of relationship and educational level did not predict relative's accuracy.

KW - aphasia

KW - cerebrovascular accident

U2 - 10.3109/13682829209029421

DO - 10.3109/13682829209029421

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 209

EP - 219

JO - European Journal of Disorders of Communication

JF - European Journal of Disorders of Communication

SN - 0963-7273

IS - 3

ER -