Finding Tolerance without Gluts

Jc Beall*

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Weber, Colyvan, and Priest have advanced glutty (dialetheic) approaches to the sorites, on which the truth about the penumbral region of a soritical series is inconsistent. The major benefit of a glut-based approach is maintaining the truth of all sorites premisses while none the less avoiding, in a principled fashion, the absurdity of the sorites conclusion(s). I agree that this is a major virtue of the target glutty approach; however, I think that it can be had without gluts. If correct, this result weighs heavily against the proposed glutty approach, at least given the default-consistency principle that all target glutty philosophers accept: posit gluts only if there is no consistent theory that enjoys the same virtues as the would-be glutty solution.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)791-811
Number of pages21
JournalMind
Volume123
Issue number491
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jul 2014

Cite this

Finding Tolerance without Gluts. / Beall, Jc.

In: Mind, Vol. 123, No. 491, 01.07.2014, p. 791-811.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Beall, J 2014, 'Finding Tolerance without Gluts', Mind, vol. 123, no. 491, pp. 791-811. https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/fzu081
Beall, Jc. / Finding Tolerance without Gluts. In: Mind. 2014 ; Vol. 123, No. 491. pp. 791-811.
@article{5cb4a6404cc74fedae6c419edb6fa81c,
title = "Finding Tolerance without Gluts",
abstract = "Weber, Colyvan, and Priest have advanced glutty (dialetheic) approaches to the sorites, on which the truth about the penumbral region of a soritical series is inconsistent. The major benefit of a glut-based approach is maintaining the truth of all sorites premisses while none the less avoiding, in a principled fashion, the absurdity of the sorites conclusion(s). I agree that this is a major virtue of the target glutty approach; however, I think that it can be had without gluts. If correct, this result weighs heavily against the proposed glutty approach, at least given the default-consistency principle that all target glutty philosophers accept: posit gluts only if there is no consistent theory that enjoys the same virtues as the would-be glutty solution.",
author = "Jc Beall",
year = "2014",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1093/mind/fzu081",
language = "English",
volume = "123",
pages = "791--811",
journal = "Mind",
issn = "0026-4423",
publisher = "OXFORD UNIV PRESS",
number = "491",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Finding Tolerance without Gluts

AU - Beall, Jc

PY - 2014/7/1

Y1 - 2014/7/1

N2 - Weber, Colyvan, and Priest have advanced glutty (dialetheic) approaches to the sorites, on which the truth about the penumbral region of a soritical series is inconsistent. The major benefit of a glut-based approach is maintaining the truth of all sorites premisses while none the less avoiding, in a principled fashion, the absurdity of the sorites conclusion(s). I agree that this is a major virtue of the target glutty approach; however, I think that it can be had without gluts. If correct, this result weighs heavily against the proposed glutty approach, at least given the default-consistency principle that all target glutty philosophers accept: posit gluts only if there is no consistent theory that enjoys the same virtues as the would-be glutty solution.

AB - Weber, Colyvan, and Priest have advanced glutty (dialetheic) approaches to the sorites, on which the truth about the penumbral region of a soritical series is inconsistent. The major benefit of a glut-based approach is maintaining the truth of all sorites premisses while none the less avoiding, in a principled fashion, the absurdity of the sorites conclusion(s). I agree that this is a major virtue of the target glutty approach; however, I think that it can be had without gluts. If correct, this result weighs heavily against the proposed glutty approach, at least given the default-consistency principle that all target glutty philosophers accept: posit gluts only if there is no consistent theory that enjoys the same virtues as the would-be glutty solution.

U2 - 10.1093/mind/fzu081

DO - 10.1093/mind/fzu081

M3 - Article

VL - 123

SP - 791

EP - 811

JO - Mind

JF - Mind

SN - 0026-4423

IS - 491

ER -