Global patterns of bioturbation intensity and mixed depth of marine soft sediments

L. R. Teal, M. T. Bulling, E. R. Parker, M. Solan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

109 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The importance of bioturbation in mediating biogeochemical processes in the upper centimetres of oceanic sediments provides a compelling reason for wanting to quantify in situ rates of bioturbation. Whilst several approaches can be used for estimating the rate and extent of bioturbation, most often it is characterized by calculating an intensity coefficient (D-b) and/or a mixed layer depth (L). Using measures of D-b (n = 447) and L (n = 784) collated largely from peer-reviewed literature, we have assembled a global database and examined patterns of both L and Db. At the broadest level, this database reveals that there are considerable gaps in our knowledge of bioturbation for all major oceans other than the North Atlantic, and almost universally for the deep ocean. Similarly, there is an appreciable bias towards observations in the Northern Hemisphere, particularly along the coastal regions of North America and Europe. For the assembled dataset, we find large discrepancies in estimations of L and Db that reflect differences in boundary conditions and reaction properties of the methods used. Tracers with longer half-lives tend to give lower Db estimates and deeper mixing depths than tracers with shorter half-lives. Estimates of L based on sediment profile imaging are significantly lower than estimates based on tracer methods. Estimations of L, but not Db, differ between biogeographical realms at the global level and, at least for the Temperate Northern Atlantic realm, also at the regional level. There are significant effects of season irrespective of location, with higher activities (Db) observed during summer and deeper mixing depths (L) observed during autumn. Our evaluation demonstrates that we have reasonable estimates of bioturbation for only a limited set of conditions and regions of the world. For these data, and based on a conservative global mean (+/- SD) L of 5.75 +/- 5.67 cm (n = 791), we calculate the global volume of bioturbated sediment to be > 20 700 km(3). Whilst it is clear that the role of benthic invertebrates in mediating global ecosystem processes is substantial, the level of uncertainty at the regional level is unacceptably high for much of the globe.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)207-218
Number of pages12
JournalAquatic Biology
Volume2
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2008

Keywords

  • bioturbation
  • sediment mixed depth
  • bioturbation coefficient
  • global analysis
  • tracer
  • sediment profile imaging
  • deep-sea sediments
  • organic-matter
  • Northeast Atlantic
  • tracer technique
  • standing stock
  • Weddell Sea
  • in-situ
  • Antartica
  • profiles
  • rates

Cite this

Global patterns of bioturbation intensity and mixed depth of marine soft sediments. / Teal, L. R.; Bulling, M. T.; Parker, E. R.; Solan, M.

In: Aquatic Biology, Vol. 2, No. 3, 2008, p. 207-218.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Teal, L. R. ; Bulling, M. T. ; Parker, E. R. ; Solan, M. / Global patterns of bioturbation intensity and mixed depth of marine soft sediments. In: Aquatic Biology. 2008 ; Vol. 2, No. 3. pp. 207-218.
@article{a3a96b580b1847b8bc6fe3714c164a13,
title = "Global patterns of bioturbation intensity and mixed depth of marine soft sediments",
abstract = "The importance of bioturbation in mediating biogeochemical processes in the upper centimetres of oceanic sediments provides a compelling reason for wanting to quantify in situ rates of bioturbation. Whilst several approaches can be used for estimating the rate and extent of bioturbation, most often it is characterized by calculating an intensity coefficient (D-b) and/or a mixed layer depth (L). Using measures of D-b (n = 447) and L (n = 784) collated largely from peer-reviewed literature, we have assembled a global database and examined patterns of both L and Db. At the broadest level, this database reveals that there are considerable gaps in our knowledge of bioturbation for all major oceans other than the North Atlantic, and almost universally for the deep ocean. Similarly, there is an appreciable bias towards observations in the Northern Hemisphere, particularly along the coastal regions of North America and Europe. For the assembled dataset, we find large discrepancies in estimations of L and Db that reflect differences in boundary conditions and reaction properties of the methods used. Tracers with longer half-lives tend to give lower Db estimates and deeper mixing depths than tracers with shorter half-lives. Estimates of L based on sediment profile imaging are significantly lower than estimates based on tracer methods. Estimations of L, but not Db, differ between biogeographical realms at the global level and, at least for the Temperate Northern Atlantic realm, also at the regional level. There are significant effects of season irrespective of location, with higher activities (Db) observed during summer and deeper mixing depths (L) observed during autumn. Our evaluation demonstrates that we have reasonable estimates of bioturbation for only a limited set of conditions and regions of the world. For these data, and based on a conservative global mean (+/- SD) L of 5.75 +/- 5.67 cm (n = 791), we calculate the global volume of bioturbated sediment to be > 20 700 km(3). Whilst it is clear that the role of benthic invertebrates in mediating global ecosystem processes is substantial, the level of uncertainty at the regional level is unacceptably high for much of the globe.",
keywords = "bioturbation, sediment mixed depth, bioturbation coefficient, global analysis, tracer, sediment profile imaging, deep-sea sediments, organic-matter, Northeast Atlantic, tracer technique, standing stock, Weddell Sea, in-situ, Antartica, profiles, rates",
author = "Teal, {L. R.} and Bulling, {M. T.} and Parker, {E. R.} and M. Solan",
year = "2008",
doi = "10.3354/ab00052",
language = "English",
volume = "2",
pages = "207--218",
journal = "Aquatic Biology",
issn = "1864-7782",
publisher = "Inter-Research",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Global patterns of bioturbation intensity and mixed depth of marine soft sediments

AU - Teal, L. R.

AU - Bulling, M. T.

AU - Parker, E. R.

AU - Solan, M.

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - The importance of bioturbation in mediating biogeochemical processes in the upper centimetres of oceanic sediments provides a compelling reason for wanting to quantify in situ rates of bioturbation. Whilst several approaches can be used for estimating the rate and extent of bioturbation, most often it is characterized by calculating an intensity coefficient (D-b) and/or a mixed layer depth (L). Using measures of D-b (n = 447) and L (n = 784) collated largely from peer-reviewed literature, we have assembled a global database and examined patterns of both L and Db. At the broadest level, this database reveals that there are considerable gaps in our knowledge of bioturbation for all major oceans other than the North Atlantic, and almost universally for the deep ocean. Similarly, there is an appreciable bias towards observations in the Northern Hemisphere, particularly along the coastal regions of North America and Europe. For the assembled dataset, we find large discrepancies in estimations of L and Db that reflect differences in boundary conditions and reaction properties of the methods used. Tracers with longer half-lives tend to give lower Db estimates and deeper mixing depths than tracers with shorter half-lives. Estimates of L based on sediment profile imaging are significantly lower than estimates based on tracer methods. Estimations of L, but not Db, differ between biogeographical realms at the global level and, at least for the Temperate Northern Atlantic realm, also at the regional level. There are significant effects of season irrespective of location, with higher activities (Db) observed during summer and deeper mixing depths (L) observed during autumn. Our evaluation demonstrates that we have reasonable estimates of bioturbation for only a limited set of conditions and regions of the world. For these data, and based on a conservative global mean (+/- SD) L of 5.75 +/- 5.67 cm (n = 791), we calculate the global volume of bioturbated sediment to be > 20 700 km(3). Whilst it is clear that the role of benthic invertebrates in mediating global ecosystem processes is substantial, the level of uncertainty at the regional level is unacceptably high for much of the globe.

AB - The importance of bioturbation in mediating biogeochemical processes in the upper centimetres of oceanic sediments provides a compelling reason for wanting to quantify in situ rates of bioturbation. Whilst several approaches can be used for estimating the rate and extent of bioturbation, most often it is characterized by calculating an intensity coefficient (D-b) and/or a mixed layer depth (L). Using measures of D-b (n = 447) and L (n = 784) collated largely from peer-reviewed literature, we have assembled a global database and examined patterns of both L and Db. At the broadest level, this database reveals that there are considerable gaps in our knowledge of bioturbation for all major oceans other than the North Atlantic, and almost universally for the deep ocean. Similarly, there is an appreciable bias towards observations in the Northern Hemisphere, particularly along the coastal regions of North America and Europe. For the assembled dataset, we find large discrepancies in estimations of L and Db that reflect differences in boundary conditions and reaction properties of the methods used. Tracers with longer half-lives tend to give lower Db estimates and deeper mixing depths than tracers with shorter half-lives. Estimates of L based on sediment profile imaging are significantly lower than estimates based on tracer methods. Estimations of L, but not Db, differ between biogeographical realms at the global level and, at least for the Temperate Northern Atlantic realm, also at the regional level. There are significant effects of season irrespective of location, with higher activities (Db) observed during summer and deeper mixing depths (L) observed during autumn. Our evaluation demonstrates that we have reasonable estimates of bioturbation for only a limited set of conditions and regions of the world. For these data, and based on a conservative global mean (+/- SD) L of 5.75 +/- 5.67 cm (n = 791), we calculate the global volume of bioturbated sediment to be > 20 700 km(3). Whilst it is clear that the role of benthic invertebrates in mediating global ecosystem processes is substantial, the level of uncertainty at the regional level is unacceptably high for much of the globe.

KW - bioturbation

KW - sediment mixed depth

KW - bioturbation coefficient

KW - global analysis

KW - tracer

KW - sediment profile imaging

KW - deep-sea sediments

KW - organic-matter

KW - Northeast Atlantic

KW - tracer technique

KW - standing stock

KW - Weddell Sea

KW - in-situ

KW - Antartica

KW - profiles

KW - rates

U2 - 10.3354/ab00052

DO - 10.3354/ab00052

M3 - Article

VL - 2

SP - 207

EP - 218

JO - Aquatic Biology

JF - Aquatic Biology

SN - 1864-7782

IS - 3

ER -