Health demonstration projects: Evaluating a community-based health intervention programme to improve young people's sexual health

Janet Stephen Tucker, Edwin Roland Van Teijlingen, Kathleen Lesley Philip, J. Shucksmith, G Penney

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

54 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

There has been criticism of systematic reviews and meta-analyses that have shown little evidence of effect of interventions to improve teenage sexual health. Moreover, there is considerable controversy surrounding the validity of outcomes and rigour of design in evaluation methods for community-based programmes. In this climate, Scotland launched Healthy Respect, one of four community-based national Demonstration Projects, to address teenage sexual health. Healthy Respect is a complex and multi-stranded intervention in Lothian Region that includes education and health-promotion activities and alternative ways to provide sexual health services for young people. A multidisciplinary research team at the University of Aberdeen was appointed to undertake an independent evaluation of this demonstration project. Challenging some aspects of theory-based evaluation, it is argued that adopting both quantitative and qualitative methods will provide an understanding of both the context and process of this Health Demonstration Project, as well as tracking outcomes, including behavioural change, in the target population. The authors’ evaluation includes: examining the process of implementation; comparative regional mapping of the service context including inter-agency partnership working; and assessing effectiveness using a quasi-experimental design and adjusted, population-based, behavioural and sexual health outcomes. Evaluation from these key perspectives contributes to a balanced appraisal of a complex, community-based health promotion and service delivery intervention.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)175-189
Number of pages15
JournalCritical Public Health
Volume16
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2006

Fingerprint

Reproductive Health
Health
Health Promotion
Health Services
Health Services Needs and Demand
Scotland
Climate
Meta-Analysis
Research Design
Education
Research
Population

Keywords

  • evaluation
  • quantitative and qualitative methods
  • community-based demonstration project
  • sexual health
  • teenage

Cite this

Health demonstration projects : Evaluating a community-based health intervention programme to improve young people's sexual health. / Tucker, Janet Stephen; Van Teijlingen, Edwin Roland; Philip, Kathleen Lesley; Shucksmith, J.; Penney, G.

In: Critical Public Health, Vol. 16, No. 3, 2006, p. 175-189.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Tucker, Janet Stephen ; Van Teijlingen, Edwin Roland ; Philip, Kathleen Lesley ; Shucksmith, J. ; Penney, G. / Health demonstration projects : Evaluating a community-based health intervention programme to improve young people's sexual health. In: Critical Public Health. 2006 ; Vol. 16, No. 3. pp. 175-189.
@article{7393e230db654f42836c810d4cffa9bf,
title = "Health demonstration projects: Evaluating a community-based health intervention programme to improve young people's sexual health",
abstract = "There has been criticism of systematic reviews and meta-analyses that have shown little evidence of effect of interventions to improve teenage sexual health. Moreover, there is considerable controversy surrounding the validity of outcomes and rigour of design in evaluation methods for community-based programmes. In this climate, Scotland launched Healthy Respect, one of four community-based national Demonstration Projects, to address teenage sexual health. Healthy Respect is a complex and multi-stranded intervention in Lothian Region that includes education and health-promotion activities and alternative ways to provide sexual health services for young people. A multidisciplinary research team at the University of Aberdeen was appointed to undertake an independent evaluation of this demonstration project. Challenging some aspects of theory-based evaluation, it is argued that adopting both quantitative and qualitative methods will provide an understanding of both the context and process of this Health Demonstration Project, as well as tracking outcomes, including behavioural change, in the target population. The authors’ evaluation includes: examining the process of implementation; comparative regional mapping of the service context including inter-agency partnership working; and assessing effectiveness using a quasi-experimental design and adjusted, population-based, behavioural and sexual health outcomes. Evaluation from these key perspectives contributes to a balanced appraisal of a complex, community-based health promotion and service delivery intervention.",
keywords = "evaluation, quantitative and qualitative methods, community-based demonstration project, sexual health, teenage",
author = "Tucker, {Janet Stephen} and {Van Teijlingen}, {Edwin Roland} and Philip, {Kathleen Lesley} and J. Shucksmith and G Penney",
year = "2006",
doi = "10.1080/09581590600986358",
language = "English",
volume = "16",
pages = "175--189",
journal = "Critical Public Health",
issn = "0958-1596",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Health demonstration projects

T2 - Evaluating a community-based health intervention programme to improve young people's sexual health

AU - Tucker, Janet Stephen

AU - Van Teijlingen, Edwin Roland

AU - Philip, Kathleen Lesley

AU - Shucksmith, J.

AU - Penney, G

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - There has been criticism of systematic reviews and meta-analyses that have shown little evidence of effect of interventions to improve teenage sexual health. Moreover, there is considerable controversy surrounding the validity of outcomes and rigour of design in evaluation methods for community-based programmes. In this climate, Scotland launched Healthy Respect, one of four community-based national Demonstration Projects, to address teenage sexual health. Healthy Respect is a complex and multi-stranded intervention in Lothian Region that includes education and health-promotion activities and alternative ways to provide sexual health services for young people. A multidisciplinary research team at the University of Aberdeen was appointed to undertake an independent evaluation of this demonstration project. Challenging some aspects of theory-based evaluation, it is argued that adopting both quantitative and qualitative methods will provide an understanding of both the context and process of this Health Demonstration Project, as well as tracking outcomes, including behavioural change, in the target population. The authors’ evaluation includes: examining the process of implementation; comparative regional mapping of the service context including inter-agency partnership working; and assessing effectiveness using a quasi-experimental design and adjusted, population-based, behavioural and sexual health outcomes. Evaluation from these key perspectives contributes to a balanced appraisal of a complex, community-based health promotion and service delivery intervention.

AB - There has been criticism of systematic reviews and meta-analyses that have shown little evidence of effect of interventions to improve teenage sexual health. Moreover, there is considerable controversy surrounding the validity of outcomes and rigour of design in evaluation methods for community-based programmes. In this climate, Scotland launched Healthy Respect, one of four community-based national Demonstration Projects, to address teenage sexual health. Healthy Respect is a complex and multi-stranded intervention in Lothian Region that includes education and health-promotion activities and alternative ways to provide sexual health services for young people. A multidisciplinary research team at the University of Aberdeen was appointed to undertake an independent evaluation of this demonstration project. Challenging some aspects of theory-based evaluation, it is argued that adopting both quantitative and qualitative methods will provide an understanding of both the context and process of this Health Demonstration Project, as well as tracking outcomes, including behavioural change, in the target population. The authors’ evaluation includes: examining the process of implementation; comparative regional mapping of the service context including inter-agency partnership working; and assessing effectiveness using a quasi-experimental design and adjusted, population-based, behavioural and sexual health outcomes. Evaluation from these key perspectives contributes to a balanced appraisal of a complex, community-based health promotion and service delivery intervention.

KW - evaluation

KW - quantitative and qualitative methods

KW - community-based demonstration project

KW - sexual health

KW - teenage

U2 - 10.1080/09581590600986358

DO - 10.1080/09581590600986358

M3 - Article

VL - 16

SP - 175

EP - 189

JO - Critical Public Health

JF - Critical Public Health

SN - 0958-1596

IS - 3

ER -