Managing ambiguity in reference generation: the role of surface structure

Imtiaz Hussain Khan, Kees van Deemter, Graeme D Ritchie

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article explores the role of surface ambiguities in referring expressions, and how the risk of such ambiguities should be taken into account by an algorithm that generates referring expressions, if these expressions are to be optimally effective for a hearer. We focus on the ambiguities that arise when adjectives occur in coordinated structures. The central idea is to use statistical information about lexical co-occurrence to estimate which interpretation of a phrase is most likely for human readers, and to avoid generating phrases where misunderstandings are likely. Various aspects of the problem were explored in three experiments in which responses by human participants provided evidence about which reading was most likely for certain phrases, which phrases were deemed most suitable for particular referents, and the speed at which various phrases were read. We found a preference for ‘‘clear’’ expressions to ‘‘unclear’’ ones, but if several of the expressions are ‘‘clear,’’ then brief expressions are preferred over non-brief ones even though the brief ones are syntactically ambiguous and the non-brief ones are not; the notion of clarity was made precise using Kilgarriff's Word Sketches. We outline an implemented algorithm that generates noun phrases conforming to our hypotheses.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)211-231
Number of pages21
JournalTopics in Cognitive Science
Volume4
Issue number2
Early online date10 Nov 2011
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2012

Fingerprint

Surface structure
Reading
interpretation
experiment
evidence
Experiments

Keywords

  • natural language generation
  • generation of referring expressions
  • ambiguity management
  • surface ambiguity in gre
  • surface realization

Cite this

Managing ambiguity in reference generation : the role of surface structure. / Khan, Imtiaz Hussain; van Deemter, Kees; Ritchie, Graeme D.

In: Topics in Cognitive Science, Vol. 4, No. 2, 04.2012, p. 211-231.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Khan, Imtiaz Hussain ; van Deemter, Kees ; Ritchie, Graeme D. / Managing ambiguity in reference generation : the role of surface structure. In: Topics in Cognitive Science. 2012 ; Vol. 4, No. 2. pp. 211-231.
@article{260d5c2fba544c27bb6994e30cf62619,
title = "Managing ambiguity in reference generation: the role of surface structure",
abstract = "This article explores the role of surface ambiguities in referring expressions, and how the risk of such ambiguities should be taken into account by an algorithm that generates referring expressions, if these expressions are to be optimally effective for a hearer. We focus on the ambiguities that arise when adjectives occur in coordinated structures. The central idea is to use statistical information about lexical co-occurrence to estimate which interpretation of a phrase is most likely for human readers, and to avoid generating phrases where misunderstandings are likely. Various aspects of the problem were explored in three experiments in which responses by human participants provided evidence about which reading was most likely for certain phrases, which phrases were deemed most suitable for particular referents, and the speed at which various phrases were read. We found a preference for ‘‘clear’’ expressions to ‘‘unclear’’ ones, but if several of the expressions are ‘‘clear,’’ then brief expressions are preferred over non-brief ones even though the brief ones are syntactically ambiguous and the non-brief ones are not; the notion of clarity was made precise using Kilgarriff's Word Sketches. We outline an implemented algorithm that generates noun phrases conforming to our hypotheses.",
keywords = "natural language generation, generation of referring expressions , ambiguity management, surface ambiguity in gre, surface realization",
author = "Khan, {Imtiaz Hussain} and {van Deemter}, Kees and Ritchie, {Graeme D}",
year = "2012",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1111/j.1756-8765.2011.01167.x",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
pages = "211--231",
journal = "Topics in Cognitive Science",
issn = "1756-8757",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Managing ambiguity in reference generation

T2 - the role of surface structure

AU - Khan, Imtiaz Hussain

AU - van Deemter, Kees

AU - Ritchie, Graeme D

PY - 2012/4

Y1 - 2012/4

N2 - This article explores the role of surface ambiguities in referring expressions, and how the risk of such ambiguities should be taken into account by an algorithm that generates referring expressions, if these expressions are to be optimally effective for a hearer. We focus on the ambiguities that arise when adjectives occur in coordinated structures. The central idea is to use statistical information about lexical co-occurrence to estimate which interpretation of a phrase is most likely for human readers, and to avoid generating phrases where misunderstandings are likely. Various aspects of the problem were explored in three experiments in which responses by human participants provided evidence about which reading was most likely for certain phrases, which phrases were deemed most suitable for particular referents, and the speed at which various phrases were read. We found a preference for ‘‘clear’’ expressions to ‘‘unclear’’ ones, but if several of the expressions are ‘‘clear,’’ then brief expressions are preferred over non-brief ones even though the brief ones are syntactically ambiguous and the non-brief ones are not; the notion of clarity was made precise using Kilgarriff's Word Sketches. We outline an implemented algorithm that generates noun phrases conforming to our hypotheses.

AB - This article explores the role of surface ambiguities in referring expressions, and how the risk of such ambiguities should be taken into account by an algorithm that generates referring expressions, if these expressions are to be optimally effective for a hearer. We focus on the ambiguities that arise when adjectives occur in coordinated structures. The central idea is to use statistical information about lexical co-occurrence to estimate which interpretation of a phrase is most likely for human readers, and to avoid generating phrases where misunderstandings are likely. Various aspects of the problem were explored in three experiments in which responses by human participants provided evidence about which reading was most likely for certain phrases, which phrases were deemed most suitable for particular referents, and the speed at which various phrases were read. We found a preference for ‘‘clear’’ expressions to ‘‘unclear’’ ones, but if several of the expressions are ‘‘clear,’’ then brief expressions are preferred over non-brief ones even though the brief ones are syntactically ambiguous and the non-brief ones are not; the notion of clarity was made precise using Kilgarriff's Word Sketches. We outline an implemented algorithm that generates noun phrases conforming to our hypotheses.

KW - natural language generation

KW - generation of referring expressions

KW - ambiguity management

KW - surface ambiguity in gre

KW - surface realization

U2 - 10.1111/j.1756-8765.2011.01167.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1756-8765.2011.01167.x

M3 - Article

VL - 4

SP - 211

EP - 231

JO - Topics in Cognitive Science

JF - Topics in Cognitive Science

SN - 1756-8757

IS - 2

ER -