Root-shoot growth responses during interspecific competition quantified using allometric modelling

David Robinson, Hazel Davidson, Clare Trinder, Robin Brooker

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

23 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background and Aims Plant competition studies are restricted by the difficulty of quantifying root systems of competitors. Analyses are usually limited to above-ground traits. Here, a new approach to address this issue is reported.

Methods Root system weights of competing plants can be estimated from: shoot weights of competitors; combined root weights of competitors; and slopes (scaling exponents, a) and intercepts (allometric coefficients, ß) of ln-regressions of root weight on shoot weight of isolated plants. If competition induces no change in root : shoot growth, a and ß values of competing and isolated plants will be equal. Measured combined root weight of competitors will equal that estimated allometrically from measured shoot weights of each competing plant. Combined root weights can be partitioned directly among competitors. If, as will be more usual, competition changes relative root and shoot growth, the competitors' combined root weight will not equal that estimated allometrically and cannot be partitioned directly. However, if the isolated-plant a and ß values are adjusted until the estimated combined root weight of competitors matches the measured combined root weight, the latter can be partitioned among competitors using their new a and ß values. The approach is illustrated using two herbaceous species, Dactylis glomerata and Plantago lanceolata.

Key Results Allometric modelling revealed a large and continuous increase in the root : shoot ratio by Dactylis, but not Plantago, during competition. This was associated with a superior whole-plant dry weight increase in Dactylis, which was ultimately 2·5-fold greater than that of Plantago. Whole-plant growth dominance of Dactylis over Plantago, as deduced from allometric modelling, occurred 14–24 d earlier than suggested by shoot data alone.

Conclusion Given reasonable assumptions, allometric modelling can analyse competitive interactions in any species mixture, and overcomes a long-standing problem in studies of competition.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)921-926
Number of pages6
JournalAnnals of Botany
Volume106
Issue number6
Early online date9 Sep 2010
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2010

Fingerprint

interspecific competition
shoots
Dactylis
Plantago
root systems
Plantago lanceolata
plant competition
Dactylis glomerata
root shoot ratio
plant growth

Keywords

  • allocation
  • allometry
  • competition
  • dry weight
  • Dactylis glomerata
  • growth
  • modelling
  • Plantago lanceolata
  • root
  • shoot
  • whole-plant

Cite this

Root-shoot growth responses during interspecific competition quantified using allometric modelling. / Robinson, David; Davidson, Hazel; Trinder, Clare; Brooker, Robin.

In: Annals of Botany, Vol. 106, No. 6, 12.2010, p. 921-926.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Robinson, David ; Davidson, Hazel ; Trinder, Clare ; Brooker, Robin. / Root-shoot growth responses during interspecific competition quantified using allometric modelling. In: Annals of Botany. 2010 ; Vol. 106, No. 6. pp. 921-926.
@article{18d518189df34b11a4a6535a44848507,
title = "Root-shoot growth responses during interspecific competition quantified using allometric modelling",
abstract = "Background and Aims Plant competition studies are restricted by the difficulty of quantifying root systems of competitors. Analyses are usually limited to above-ground traits. Here, a new approach to address this issue is reported. Methods Root system weights of competing plants can be estimated from: shoot weights of competitors; combined root weights of competitors; and slopes (scaling exponents, a) and intercepts (allometric coefficients, {\ss}) of ln-regressions of root weight on shoot weight of isolated plants. If competition induces no change in root : shoot growth, a and {\ss} values of competing and isolated plants will be equal. Measured combined root weight of competitors will equal that estimated allometrically from measured shoot weights of each competing plant. Combined root weights can be partitioned directly among competitors. If, as will be more usual, competition changes relative root and shoot growth, the competitors' combined root weight will not equal that estimated allometrically and cannot be partitioned directly. However, if the isolated-plant a and {\ss} values are adjusted until the estimated combined root weight of competitors matches the measured combined root weight, the latter can be partitioned among competitors using their new a and {\ss} values. The approach is illustrated using two herbaceous species, Dactylis glomerata and Plantago lanceolata. Key Results Allometric modelling revealed a large and continuous increase in the root : shoot ratio by Dactylis, but not Plantago, during competition. This was associated with a superior whole-plant dry weight increase in Dactylis, which was ultimately 2·5-fold greater than that of Plantago. Whole-plant growth dominance of Dactylis over Plantago, as deduced from allometric modelling, occurred 14–24 d earlier than suggested by shoot data alone. Conclusion Given reasonable assumptions, allometric modelling can analyse competitive interactions in any species mixture, and overcomes a long-standing problem in studies of competition.",
keywords = "allocation, allometry, competition, dry weight, Dactylis glomerata, growth, modelling, Plantago lanceolata, root, shoot, whole-plant",
author = "David Robinson and Hazel Davidson and Clare Trinder and Robin Brooker",
note = "ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We are grateful to two reviewers for their helpful comments. This work was supported by the Natural Environment Research Council (NE/F004591/1).",
year = "2010",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1093/aob/mcq186",
language = "English",
volume = "106",
pages = "921--926",
journal = "Annals of Botany",
issn = "0305-7364",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Root-shoot growth responses during interspecific competition quantified using allometric modelling

AU - Robinson, David

AU - Davidson, Hazel

AU - Trinder, Clare

AU - Brooker, Robin

N1 - ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We are grateful to two reviewers for their helpful comments. This work was supported by the Natural Environment Research Council (NE/F004591/1).

PY - 2010/12

Y1 - 2010/12

N2 - Background and Aims Plant competition studies are restricted by the difficulty of quantifying root systems of competitors. Analyses are usually limited to above-ground traits. Here, a new approach to address this issue is reported. Methods Root system weights of competing plants can be estimated from: shoot weights of competitors; combined root weights of competitors; and slopes (scaling exponents, a) and intercepts (allometric coefficients, ß) of ln-regressions of root weight on shoot weight of isolated plants. If competition induces no change in root : shoot growth, a and ß values of competing and isolated plants will be equal. Measured combined root weight of competitors will equal that estimated allometrically from measured shoot weights of each competing plant. Combined root weights can be partitioned directly among competitors. If, as will be more usual, competition changes relative root and shoot growth, the competitors' combined root weight will not equal that estimated allometrically and cannot be partitioned directly. However, if the isolated-plant a and ß values are adjusted until the estimated combined root weight of competitors matches the measured combined root weight, the latter can be partitioned among competitors using their new a and ß values. The approach is illustrated using two herbaceous species, Dactylis glomerata and Plantago lanceolata. Key Results Allometric modelling revealed a large and continuous increase in the root : shoot ratio by Dactylis, but not Plantago, during competition. This was associated with a superior whole-plant dry weight increase in Dactylis, which was ultimately 2·5-fold greater than that of Plantago. Whole-plant growth dominance of Dactylis over Plantago, as deduced from allometric modelling, occurred 14–24 d earlier than suggested by shoot data alone. Conclusion Given reasonable assumptions, allometric modelling can analyse competitive interactions in any species mixture, and overcomes a long-standing problem in studies of competition.

AB - Background and Aims Plant competition studies are restricted by the difficulty of quantifying root systems of competitors. Analyses are usually limited to above-ground traits. Here, a new approach to address this issue is reported. Methods Root system weights of competing plants can be estimated from: shoot weights of competitors; combined root weights of competitors; and slopes (scaling exponents, a) and intercepts (allometric coefficients, ß) of ln-regressions of root weight on shoot weight of isolated plants. If competition induces no change in root : shoot growth, a and ß values of competing and isolated plants will be equal. Measured combined root weight of competitors will equal that estimated allometrically from measured shoot weights of each competing plant. Combined root weights can be partitioned directly among competitors. If, as will be more usual, competition changes relative root and shoot growth, the competitors' combined root weight will not equal that estimated allometrically and cannot be partitioned directly. However, if the isolated-plant a and ß values are adjusted until the estimated combined root weight of competitors matches the measured combined root weight, the latter can be partitioned among competitors using their new a and ß values. The approach is illustrated using two herbaceous species, Dactylis glomerata and Plantago lanceolata. Key Results Allometric modelling revealed a large and continuous increase in the root : shoot ratio by Dactylis, but not Plantago, during competition. This was associated with a superior whole-plant dry weight increase in Dactylis, which was ultimately 2·5-fold greater than that of Plantago. Whole-plant growth dominance of Dactylis over Plantago, as deduced from allometric modelling, occurred 14–24 d earlier than suggested by shoot data alone. Conclusion Given reasonable assumptions, allometric modelling can analyse competitive interactions in any species mixture, and overcomes a long-standing problem in studies of competition.

KW - allocation

KW - allometry

KW - competition

KW - dry weight

KW - Dactylis glomerata

KW - growth

KW - modelling

KW - Plantago lanceolata

KW - root

KW - shoot

KW - whole-plant

U2 - 10.1093/aob/mcq186

DO - 10.1093/aob/mcq186

M3 - Article

VL - 106

SP - 921

EP - 926

JO - Annals of Botany

JF - Annals of Botany

SN - 0305-7364

IS - 6

ER -