Spatial organisation of drumlins

Chris D. Clark, Jeremy C. Ely, Matteo Spagnolo, Ute Hahn, Anna L. C. Hughes, Chris R. Stokes

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)
4 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Ice-sheets flowing over soft sediments produce undulations in the bed, typically of metres in relief, of which drumlins are the most abundant and widely investigated. Consensus regarding their mechanism of formation has yet to be achieved. In this paper we examine the spatial organisation of drumlins in order to provide an improved description of the phenomenon and to guide hypotheses of their formation. We review the literature highlighting contradictory findings regarding drumlin spatial organisation and then use this to motivate our study based on a large sample (42,488) of drumlins from Canada, Britain and Norway. Are there typical arrangements in drumlin positioning and are they organised in a regular spatial manner (patterned) or are they distributed randomly? We recognise that drumlin fields are inherently patchy and therefore apply inhomogeneous spatial statistics in order to study their distribution. This shows that whilst drumlins are occasionally randomly placed, their main state is non- random. They exhibit a strong and statistically significant signal of regularity across lengths scales of 100 – 1200 m. We conclude that patterning is a near ubiquitous property of drumlins. This finding of regularity demonstrates spatial self-organisation in the bedforming process with drumlins as an emergent manifestation of subglacial sediment mobility. Kilometre-scale interactions between drumlins must occur as they evolve, or interactions may arise as a consequence of growth or migration. Hypotheses or models are required that can explain the regular spacing of drumlins. We highlight three suggestions for such self-organisation: instability in the coupling of ice flow - sediment flux - bed shape; local feedback between sediment mobility and relief; and coarsening by growth or migration.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)499-513
Number of pages15
JournalEarth Surface Processes and Landforms
Volume43
Issue number2
Early online date18 Jul 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2018

Fingerprint

drumlin
self-organization
regularity
migration
interaction
Norway
statistics
Canada
self organization
sediment
relief
ice flow
positioning
ice sheet
spacing
literature

Keywords

  • drumlins
  • patterning
  • regularity
  • subglacial bedforms
  • self-organisation

Cite this

Clark, C. D., Ely, J. C., Spagnolo, M., Hahn, U., Hughes, A. L. C., & Stokes, C. R. (2018). Spatial organisation of drumlins. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 43(2), 499-513. https://doi.org/10.1002/esp.4192

Spatial organisation of drumlins. / Clark, Chris D.; Ely, Jeremy C.; Spagnolo, Matteo; Hahn, Ute; Hughes, Anna L. C.; Stokes, Chris R.

In: Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, Vol. 43, No. 2, 02.2018, p. 499-513.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Clark, CD, Ely, JC, Spagnolo, M, Hahn, U, Hughes, ALC & Stokes, CR 2018, 'Spatial organisation of drumlins', Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 499-513. https://doi.org/10.1002/esp.4192
Clark CD, Ely JC, Spagnolo M, Hahn U, Hughes ALC, Stokes CR. Spatial organisation of drumlins. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms. 2018 Feb;43(2):499-513. https://doi.org/10.1002/esp.4192
Clark, Chris D. ; Ely, Jeremy C. ; Spagnolo, Matteo ; Hahn, Ute ; Hughes, Anna L. C. ; Stokes, Chris R. / Spatial organisation of drumlins. In: Earth Surface Processes and Landforms. 2018 ; Vol. 43, No. 2. pp. 499-513.
@article{8c8cfe388b7e4ed1867d8073d3bbf604,
title = "Spatial organisation of drumlins",
abstract = "Ice-sheets flowing over soft sediments produce undulations in the bed, typically of metres in relief, of which drumlins are the most abundant and widely investigated. Consensus regarding their mechanism of formation has yet to be achieved. In this paper we examine the spatial organisation of drumlins in order to provide an improved description of the phenomenon and to guide hypotheses of their formation. We review the literature highlighting contradictory findings regarding drumlin spatial organisation and then use this to motivate our study based on a large sample (42,488) of drumlins from Canada, Britain and Norway. Are there typical arrangements in drumlin positioning and are they organised in a regular spatial manner (patterned) or are they distributed randomly? We recognise that drumlin fields are inherently patchy and therefore apply inhomogeneous spatial statistics in order to study their distribution. This shows that whilst drumlins are occasionally randomly placed, their main state is non- random. They exhibit a strong and statistically significant signal of regularity across lengths scales of 100 – 1200 m. We conclude that patterning is a near ubiquitous property of drumlins. This finding of regularity demonstrates spatial self-organisation in the bedforming process with drumlins as an emergent manifestation of subglacial sediment mobility. Kilometre-scale interactions between drumlins must occur as they evolve, or interactions may arise as a consequence of growth or migration. Hypotheses or models are required that can explain the regular spacing of drumlins. We highlight three suggestions for such self-organisation: instability in the coupling of ice flow - sediment flux - bed shape; local feedback between sediment mobility and relief; and coarsening by growth or migration.",
keywords = "drumlins, patterning, regularity, subglacial bedforms, self-organisation",
author = "Clark, {Chris D.} and Ely, {Jeremy C.} and Matteo Spagnolo and Ute Hahn and Hughes, {Anna L. C.} and Stokes, {Chris R.}",
note = "Acknowledgements This work was supported by NERC grant NE/D011175/1 led by CDC. JCE was generously supported by a PhD scholarship from Kathy and Chris Denison. Andrew Fowler and Richard Hindmarsh are thanked for numerous illuminating and otherwise conversations on the topic. David Unwin and Clive Anderson are thanked for their pointers regarding spatial analysis and R software. We are grateful to referees for helping improve the paper.",
year = "2018",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1002/esp.4192",
language = "English",
volume = "43",
pages = "499--513",
journal = "Earth Surface Processes and Landforms",
issn = "0197-9337",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Spatial organisation of drumlins

AU - Clark, Chris D.

AU - Ely, Jeremy C.

AU - Spagnolo, Matteo

AU - Hahn, Ute

AU - Hughes, Anna L. C.

AU - Stokes, Chris R.

N1 - Acknowledgements This work was supported by NERC grant NE/D011175/1 led by CDC. JCE was generously supported by a PhD scholarship from Kathy and Chris Denison. Andrew Fowler and Richard Hindmarsh are thanked for numerous illuminating and otherwise conversations on the topic. David Unwin and Clive Anderson are thanked for their pointers regarding spatial analysis and R software. We are grateful to referees for helping improve the paper.

PY - 2018/2

Y1 - 2018/2

N2 - Ice-sheets flowing over soft sediments produce undulations in the bed, typically of metres in relief, of which drumlins are the most abundant and widely investigated. Consensus regarding their mechanism of formation has yet to be achieved. In this paper we examine the spatial organisation of drumlins in order to provide an improved description of the phenomenon and to guide hypotheses of their formation. We review the literature highlighting contradictory findings regarding drumlin spatial organisation and then use this to motivate our study based on a large sample (42,488) of drumlins from Canada, Britain and Norway. Are there typical arrangements in drumlin positioning and are they organised in a regular spatial manner (patterned) or are they distributed randomly? We recognise that drumlin fields are inherently patchy and therefore apply inhomogeneous spatial statistics in order to study their distribution. This shows that whilst drumlins are occasionally randomly placed, their main state is non- random. They exhibit a strong and statistically significant signal of regularity across lengths scales of 100 – 1200 m. We conclude that patterning is a near ubiquitous property of drumlins. This finding of regularity demonstrates spatial self-organisation in the bedforming process with drumlins as an emergent manifestation of subglacial sediment mobility. Kilometre-scale interactions between drumlins must occur as they evolve, or interactions may arise as a consequence of growth or migration. Hypotheses or models are required that can explain the regular spacing of drumlins. We highlight three suggestions for such self-organisation: instability in the coupling of ice flow - sediment flux - bed shape; local feedback between sediment mobility and relief; and coarsening by growth or migration.

AB - Ice-sheets flowing over soft sediments produce undulations in the bed, typically of metres in relief, of which drumlins are the most abundant and widely investigated. Consensus regarding their mechanism of formation has yet to be achieved. In this paper we examine the spatial organisation of drumlins in order to provide an improved description of the phenomenon and to guide hypotheses of their formation. We review the literature highlighting contradictory findings regarding drumlin spatial organisation and then use this to motivate our study based on a large sample (42,488) of drumlins from Canada, Britain and Norway. Are there typical arrangements in drumlin positioning and are they organised in a regular spatial manner (patterned) or are they distributed randomly? We recognise that drumlin fields are inherently patchy and therefore apply inhomogeneous spatial statistics in order to study their distribution. This shows that whilst drumlins are occasionally randomly placed, their main state is non- random. They exhibit a strong and statistically significant signal of regularity across lengths scales of 100 – 1200 m. We conclude that patterning is a near ubiquitous property of drumlins. This finding of regularity demonstrates spatial self-organisation in the bedforming process with drumlins as an emergent manifestation of subglacial sediment mobility. Kilometre-scale interactions between drumlins must occur as they evolve, or interactions may arise as a consequence of growth or migration. Hypotheses or models are required that can explain the regular spacing of drumlins. We highlight three suggestions for such self-organisation: instability in the coupling of ice flow - sediment flux - bed shape; local feedback between sediment mobility and relief; and coarsening by growth or migration.

KW - drumlins

KW - patterning

KW - regularity

KW - subglacial bedforms

KW - self-organisation

U2 - 10.1002/esp.4192

DO - 10.1002/esp.4192

M3 - Article

VL - 43

SP - 499

EP - 513

JO - Earth Surface Processes and Landforms

JF - Earth Surface Processes and Landforms

SN - 0197-9337

IS - 2

ER -