The Political Character of Legal Institutions and Its Conceptual Significance

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The essay seeks to make contributions to the clarification of the conceptual relation between law and politics. It characterizes law as an institutionalized and normative social practice that makes authority claims on its participants. On this basis, legal institutions are defined as institutions that systematically seek to influence human conduct by providing authoritatively binding practical reasons. The essay claims that the elucidation of the conceptual features of legal institutions touches upon a series of issues of justification that belong to the realm of political philosophy. This makes concepts like political institution and political obligation relevant for conceptual legal theory. After an analysis of the concept of political institution, the essay claims that the concept of legal institution and the concept of political institution have the same applications. This conclusion is used in support of the main thesis of essay: legal institutions are to be treated as political institutions in conceptual legal theory. The essay also examines whether the conceptual framework outlined here can be compatible with a viable notion of political communities. The essay makes an attempt to clarify the relevance of the main thesis in respect to legal reasoning; it insists that the position taken here is unlikely to lead to some radical reorientation of legal reasoning.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)33-50
Number of pages18
JournalActa Juridica Hungarica
Volume46
Issue number1-2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2005

Fingerprint

political institution
legal theory
legal basis
Law
political philosophy
obligation
politics
community

Keywords

  • obligation
  • authority
  • legal institution
  • the normativity of law
  • political institution
  • political obligation
  • political community
  • political legitimacy
  • legal reasoning

Cite this

The Political Character of Legal Institutions and Its Conceptual Significance. / Bodig, Matyas.

In: Acta Juridica Hungarica, Vol. 46, No. 1-2, 07.2005, p. 33-50.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{a45009f14df34b93a090164d54ca41d2,
title = "The Political Character of Legal Institutions and Its Conceptual Significance",
abstract = "The essay seeks to make contributions to the clarification of the conceptual relation between law and politics. It characterizes law as an institutionalized and normative social practice that makes authority claims on its participants. On this basis, legal institutions are defined as institutions that systematically seek to influence human conduct by providing authoritatively binding practical reasons. The essay claims that the elucidation of the conceptual features of legal institutions touches upon a series of issues of justification that belong to the realm of political philosophy. This makes concepts like political institution and political obligation relevant for conceptual legal theory. After an analysis of the concept of political institution, the essay claims that the concept of legal institution and the concept of political institution have the same applications. This conclusion is used in support of the main thesis of essay: legal institutions are to be treated as political institutions in conceptual legal theory. The essay also examines whether the conceptual framework outlined here can be compatible with a viable notion of political communities. The essay makes an attempt to clarify the relevance of the main thesis in respect to legal reasoning; it insists that the position taken here is unlikely to lead to some radical reorientation of legal reasoning.",
keywords = "obligation, authority, legal institution, the normativity of law, political institution, political obligation, political community, political legitimacy, legal reasoning",
author = "Matyas Bodig",
year = "2005",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1556/AJur.46.2005.1-2.3",
language = "English",
volume = "46",
pages = "33--50",
journal = "Acta Juridica Hungarica",
issn = "1216-2574",
publisher = "Akademiai Kiado",
number = "1-2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Political Character of Legal Institutions and Its Conceptual Significance

AU - Bodig, Matyas

PY - 2005/7

Y1 - 2005/7

N2 - The essay seeks to make contributions to the clarification of the conceptual relation between law and politics. It characterizes law as an institutionalized and normative social practice that makes authority claims on its participants. On this basis, legal institutions are defined as institutions that systematically seek to influence human conduct by providing authoritatively binding practical reasons. The essay claims that the elucidation of the conceptual features of legal institutions touches upon a series of issues of justification that belong to the realm of political philosophy. This makes concepts like political institution and political obligation relevant for conceptual legal theory. After an analysis of the concept of political institution, the essay claims that the concept of legal institution and the concept of political institution have the same applications. This conclusion is used in support of the main thesis of essay: legal institutions are to be treated as political institutions in conceptual legal theory. The essay also examines whether the conceptual framework outlined here can be compatible with a viable notion of political communities. The essay makes an attempt to clarify the relevance of the main thesis in respect to legal reasoning; it insists that the position taken here is unlikely to lead to some radical reorientation of legal reasoning.

AB - The essay seeks to make contributions to the clarification of the conceptual relation between law and politics. It characterizes law as an institutionalized and normative social practice that makes authority claims on its participants. On this basis, legal institutions are defined as institutions that systematically seek to influence human conduct by providing authoritatively binding practical reasons. The essay claims that the elucidation of the conceptual features of legal institutions touches upon a series of issues of justification that belong to the realm of political philosophy. This makes concepts like political institution and political obligation relevant for conceptual legal theory. After an analysis of the concept of political institution, the essay claims that the concept of legal institution and the concept of political institution have the same applications. This conclusion is used in support of the main thesis of essay: legal institutions are to be treated as political institutions in conceptual legal theory. The essay also examines whether the conceptual framework outlined here can be compatible with a viable notion of political communities. The essay makes an attempt to clarify the relevance of the main thesis in respect to legal reasoning; it insists that the position taken here is unlikely to lead to some radical reorientation of legal reasoning.

KW - obligation

KW - authority

KW - legal institution

KW - the normativity of law

KW - political institution

KW - political obligation

KW - political community

KW - political legitimacy

KW - legal reasoning

U2 - 10.1556/AJur.46.2005.1-2.3

DO - 10.1556/AJur.46.2005.1-2.3

M3 - Article

VL - 46

SP - 33

EP - 50

JO - Acta Juridica Hungarica

JF - Acta Juridica Hungarica

SN - 1216-2574

IS - 1-2

ER -