The role of sampling strategy on apparent temporal stability of soil moisture under subtropical hydroclimatic conditions

Lei Gao, Yaji Wang, Josie Geris, Paul D. Hallett, Xinhua Peng (Corresponding Author)

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Subtropical regions have clay-rich, weathered soils, and long dry periods followed by intense rainfall that produces large fluctuations in soil water content (SWC) and hydrological behavior. This complicates predictions of spatio-temporal dynamics, as datasets are typically collected at too coarse resolution and observations often represent a duration that is too short to capture temporal stability. The aim of the present study was to gain further insights into the role of temporal sampling scale on the observed temporal stability features of SWC order to aid the design of optimal SWC sampling strategies. This focused on both sampling frequency and total monitoring duration, as previous analyses have not considered both of these sampling aspects simultaneously. We collected relatively high resolution data of SWC (fortnightly over 3.5 years) for various soil depths and under contrasting crops (peanuts and citrus) at the red soil region of southeast China. The dataset was split into a three-year training period and a six-month evaluation period. Altogether 13 sampling frequencies (intervals ranging from 15 to 240 days) and eight monitoring duration periods (between three and 36 months) were derived from the training period to identify temporal stability features and the most time stable location (MTSL). The prediction accuracies of these MTSLs were tested using the independent evaluation data. Results showed that vegetation type did affect the spatio-temporal patterns of SWC, whereby the citrus site exhibited a stronger temporal variation and weaker temporal stability than the peanut site. However, the effects of both sampling frequency and observation duration were more pronounced, irrespective of the role of vegetation type or soil depth. With increasing sampling interval or decreasing monitoring duration, temporal stability of SWC was generally overestimated; by less than 10% when sampling interval increased from every 15 to 240 days and by up to 40% with duration decreasing from 36 to 3 months. Our results suggest that sampling strategies and trade-offs between sampling interval and duration should focus on capturing the main variability in hydro-climatological conditions. For subtropical conditions, we found that sampling once every 45 days over 24 months to be the minimum sampling strategy to ensure errors in SWC temporal stability of less than 10%.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)260-270
Number of pages11
JournalJournal of hydrology and hydromechanics
Volume67
Issue number3
Early online date26 Jun 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Sep 2019

Fingerprint

Soil moisture
soil moisture
Sampling
Soils
sampling
Water content
soil water
water content
soil depth
vegetation type
Monitoring
monitoring
red soil
subtropical region
prediction
Crops
Rain
Clay
temporal variation

Keywords

  • sampling strategy
  • subtropical climate
  • temporal stability
  • vegetation type
  • soil moisture prediction

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Water Science and Technology
  • Mechanical Engineering
  • Fluid Flow and Transfer Processes

Cite this

The role of sampling strategy on apparent temporal stability of soil moisture under subtropical hydroclimatic conditions. / Gao, Lei; Wang, Yaji; Geris, Josie; Hallett, Paul D.; Peng, Xinhua (Corresponding Author).

In: Journal of hydrology and hydromechanics, Vol. 67, No. 3, 01.09.2019, p. 260-270.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{e698aa7aae744c958798fca35b97ec0e,
title = "The role of sampling strategy on apparent temporal stability of soil moisture under subtropical hydroclimatic conditions",
abstract = "Subtropical regions have clay-rich, weathered soils, and long dry periods followed by intense rainfall that produces large fluctuations in soil water content (SWC) and hydrological behavior. This complicates predictions of spatio-temporal dynamics, as datasets are typically collected at too coarse resolution and observations often represent a duration that is too short to capture temporal stability. The aim of the present study was to gain further insights into the role of temporal sampling scale on the observed temporal stability features of SWC order to aid the design of optimal SWC sampling strategies. This focused on both sampling frequency and total monitoring duration, as previous analyses have not considered both of these sampling aspects simultaneously. We collected relatively high resolution data of SWC (fortnightly over 3.5 years) for various soil depths and under contrasting crops (peanuts and citrus) at the red soil region of southeast China. The dataset was split into a three-year training period and a six-month evaluation period. Altogether 13 sampling frequencies (intervals ranging from 15 to 240 days) and eight monitoring duration periods (between three and 36 months) were derived from the training period to identify temporal stability features and the most time stable location (MTSL). The prediction accuracies of these MTSLs were tested using the independent evaluation data. Results showed that vegetation type did affect the spatio-temporal patterns of SWC, whereby the citrus site exhibited a stronger temporal variation and weaker temporal stability than the peanut site. However, the effects of both sampling frequency and observation duration were more pronounced, irrespective of the role of vegetation type or soil depth. With increasing sampling interval or decreasing monitoring duration, temporal stability of SWC was generally overestimated; by less than 10{\%} when sampling interval increased from every 15 to 240 days and by up to 40{\%} with duration decreasing from 36 to 3 months. Our results suggest that sampling strategies and trade-offs between sampling interval and duration should focus on capturing the main variability in hydro-climatological conditions. For subtropical conditions, we found that sampling once every 45 days over 24 months to be the minimum sampling strategy to ensure errors in SWC temporal stability of less than 10{\%}.",
keywords = "sampling strategy, subtropical climate, temporal stability, vegetation type, soil moisture prediction",
author = "Lei Gao and Yaji Wang and Josie Geris and Hallett, {Paul D.} and Xinhua Peng",
note = "Financial support for this research was provided through the joint China-UK Red Soil Critical Zone project funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC: 41771263; 41571130053) and the United Kingdom Natural Environment Research Council (NE/N007611/1). Additional funding was provided by the “135 innovation project” from the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS:ISSASIP1648). Special thanks go to the staff of the Ecological Experimental Station of Red Soil of the Institute of Soil Science of CAS.",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.2478/johh-2019-0006",
language = "English",
volume = "67",
pages = "260--270",
journal = "Journal of hydrology and hydromechanics",
issn = "0042-790X",
publisher = "VEDA, SLOVAK ACAD SCIENCES",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The role of sampling strategy on apparent temporal stability of soil moisture under subtropical hydroclimatic conditions

AU - Gao, Lei

AU - Wang, Yaji

AU - Geris, Josie

AU - Hallett, Paul D.

AU - Peng, Xinhua

N1 - Financial support for this research was provided through the joint China-UK Red Soil Critical Zone project funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC: 41771263; 41571130053) and the United Kingdom Natural Environment Research Council (NE/N007611/1). Additional funding was provided by the “135 innovation project” from the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS:ISSASIP1648). Special thanks go to the staff of the Ecological Experimental Station of Red Soil of the Institute of Soil Science of CAS.

PY - 2019/9/1

Y1 - 2019/9/1

N2 - Subtropical regions have clay-rich, weathered soils, and long dry periods followed by intense rainfall that produces large fluctuations in soil water content (SWC) and hydrological behavior. This complicates predictions of spatio-temporal dynamics, as datasets are typically collected at too coarse resolution and observations often represent a duration that is too short to capture temporal stability. The aim of the present study was to gain further insights into the role of temporal sampling scale on the observed temporal stability features of SWC order to aid the design of optimal SWC sampling strategies. This focused on both sampling frequency and total monitoring duration, as previous analyses have not considered both of these sampling aspects simultaneously. We collected relatively high resolution data of SWC (fortnightly over 3.5 years) for various soil depths and under contrasting crops (peanuts and citrus) at the red soil region of southeast China. The dataset was split into a three-year training period and a six-month evaluation period. Altogether 13 sampling frequencies (intervals ranging from 15 to 240 days) and eight monitoring duration periods (between three and 36 months) were derived from the training period to identify temporal stability features and the most time stable location (MTSL). The prediction accuracies of these MTSLs were tested using the independent evaluation data. Results showed that vegetation type did affect the spatio-temporal patterns of SWC, whereby the citrus site exhibited a stronger temporal variation and weaker temporal stability than the peanut site. However, the effects of both sampling frequency and observation duration were more pronounced, irrespective of the role of vegetation type or soil depth. With increasing sampling interval or decreasing monitoring duration, temporal stability of SWC was generally overestimated; by less than 10% when sampling interval increased from every 15 to 240 days and by up to 40% with duration decreasing from 36 to 3 months. Our results suggest that sampling strategies and trade-offs between sampling interval and duration should focus on capturing the main variability in hydro-climatological conditions. For subtropical conditions, we found that sampling once every 45 days over 24 months to be the minimum sampling strategy to ensure errors in SWC temporal stability of less than 10%.

AB - Subtropical regions have clay-rich, weathered soils, and long dry periods followed by intense rainfall that produces large fluctuations in soil water content (SWC) and hydrological behavior. This complicates predictions of spatio-temporal dynamics, as datasets are typically collected at too coarse resolution and observations often represent a duration that is too short to capture temporal stability. The aim of the present study was to gain further insights into the role of temporal sampling scale on the observed temporal stability features of SWC order to aid the design of optimal SWC sampling strategies. This focused on both sampling frequency and total monitoring duration, as previous analyses have not considered both of these sampling aspects simultaneously. We collected relatively high resolution data of SWC (fortnightly over 3.5 years) for various soil depths and under contrasting crops (peanuts and citrus) at the red soil region of southeast China. The dataset was split into a three-year training period and a six-month evaluation period. Altogether 13 sampling frequencies (intervals ranging from 15 to 240 days) and eight monitoring duration periods (between three and 36 months) were derived from the training period to identify temporal stability features and the most time stable location (MTSL). The prediction accuracies of these MTSLs were tested using the independent evaluation data. Results showed that vegetation type did affect the spatio-temporal patterns of SWC, whereby the citrus site exhibited a stronger temporal variation and weaker temporal stability than the peanut site. However, the effects of both sampling frequency and observation duration were more pronounced, irrespective of the role of vegetation type or soil depth. With increasing sampling interval or decreasing monitoring duration, temporal stability of SWC was generally overestimated; by less than 10% when sampling interval increased from every 15 to 240 days and by up to 40% with duration decreasing from 36 to 3 months. Our results suggest that sampling strategies and trade-offs between sampling interval and duration should focus on capturing the main variability in hydro-climatological conditions. For subtropical conditions, we found that sampling once every 45 days over 24 months to be the minimum sampling strategy to ensure errors in SWC temporal stability of less than 10%.

KW - sampling strategy

KW - subtropical climate

KW - temporal stability

KW - vegetation type

KW - soil moisture prediction

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/role-sampling-strategy-apparent-temporal-stability-soil-moisture-under-subtropical-hydroclimatic-con

U2 - 10.2478/johh-2019-0006

DO - 10.2478/johh-2019-0006

M3 - Article

VL - 67

SP - 260

EP - 270

JO - Journal of hydrology and hydromechanics

JF - Journal of hydrology and hydromechanics

SN - 0042-790X

IS - 3

ER -