Variation in physical development in schoolboy rugby players: can maturity testing reduce mismatch?

Richard W Nutton, David F Hamilton, James D Hutchison, Martin J Mitchell, A Hamish Rw Simpson, James G B Maclean

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Citations (Scopus)
3 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: This study set out to pursue means of reducing mismatch in schoolboy rugby players. The primary objective was to determine whether application of previously reported thresholds of height and grip strength could be used to distinguish those 15-year-old boys appropriate to play under-18 school rugby from their peers. A secondary objective was to obtain normative data for height, weight and grip strength and to assess the variation within that data of current schoolboy rugby players. DESIGN: Cross-sectional cohort study. SETTING: 3 Scottish schools and 'Regional Assessment Centres' organised by the Scottish Rugby Union. PARTICIPANTS: 472 rugby playing youths aged 15 years (Regional Assessment Centres) and 382 schoolboys aged between 12 and 18 years (three schools). OUTCOME MEASURES: Height, weight and grip strength. RESULTS: 97% of 15-year-olds achieved the height and grip strength thresholds based on previous reported values. Larger mean values and wide variation of height, weight and grip strength were recorded in the schoolboy cohort. However, using the mean values of the cohort of 17-year-olds as a new threshold, only 7.7% of 15-year-olds would pass these thresholds. CONCLUSIONS: Large morphological variation was observed in schoolboy rugby players of the same age. Physical maturity tests described in earlier literature as pre-participation screening for contact sports were not applicable to current day 15-year-old rugby players. New criteria were measured and found to be better at identifying those 15-year-old players who had sufficient physical development to play senior school rugby.
Original languageEnglish
Article numbere001149
Number of pages6
JournalBMJ Open
Volume2
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2012

Fingerprint

Football
Hand Strength
Weights and Measures
Sports
Cohort Studies
Cross-Sectional Studies

Cite this

Nutton, R. W., Hamilton, D. F., Hutchison, J. D., Mitchell, M. J., Simpson, A. H. R., & Maclean, J. G. B. (2012). Variation in physical development in schoolboy rugby players: can maturity testing reduce mismatch? BMJ Open, 2(4), [e001149]. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2012-001149

Variation in physical development in schoolboy rugby players : can maturity testing reduce mismatch? / Nutton, Richard W; Hamilton, David F; Hutchison, James D; Mitchell, Martin J; Simpson, A Hamish Rw; Maclean, James G B.

In: BMJ Open, Vol. 2, No. 4, e001149, 07.2012.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Nutton, RW, Hamilton, DF, Hutchison, JD, Mitchell, MJ, Simpson, AHR & Maclean, JGB 2012, 'Variation in physical development in schoolboy rugby players: can maturity testing reduce mismatch?', BMJ Open, vol. 2, no. 4, e001149. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2012-001149
Nutton RW, Hamilton DF, Hutchison JD, Mitchell MJ, Simpson AHR, Maclean JGB. Variation in physical development in schoolboy rugby players: can maturity testing reduce mismatch? BMJ Open. 2012 Jul;2(4). e001149. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2012-001149
Nutton, Richard W ; Hamilton, David F ; Hutchison, James D ; Mitchell, Martin J ; Simpson, A Hamish Rw ; Maclean, James G B. / Variation in physical development in schoolboy rugby players : can maturity testing reduce mismatch?. In: BMJ Open. 2012 ; Vol. 2, No. 4.
@article{7d2800c37816404b8e67e641caedf1f9,
title = "Variation in physical development in schoolboy rugby players: can maturity testing reduce mismatch?",
abstract = "OBJECTIVES: This study set out to pursue means of reducing mismatch in schoolboy rugby players. The primary objective was to determine whether application of previously reported thresholds of height and grip strength could be used to distinguish those 15-year-old boys appropriate to play under-18 school rugby from their peers. A secondary objective was to obtain normative data for height, weight and grip strength and to assess the variation within that data of current schoolboy rugby players. DESIGN: Cross-sectional cohort study. SETTING: 3 Scottish schools and 'Regional Assessment Centres' organised by the Scottish Rugby Union. PARTICIPANTS: 472 rugby playing youths aged 15 years (Regional Assessment Centres) and 382 schoolboys aged between 12 and 18 years (three schools). OUTCOME MEASURES: Height, weight and grip strength. RESULTS: 97{\%} of 15-year-olds achieved the height and grip strength thresholds based on previous reported values. Larger mean values and wide variation of height, weight and grip strength were recorded in the schoolboy cohort. However, using the mean values of the cohort of 17-year-olds as a new threshold, only 7.7{\%} of 15-year-olds would pass these thresholds. CONCLUSIONS: Large morphological variation was observed in schoolboy rugby players of the same age. Physical maturity tests described in earlier literature as pre-participation screening for contact sports were not applicable to current day 15-year-old rugby players. New criteria were measured and found to be better at identifying those 15-year-old players who had sufficient physical development to play senior school rugby.",
author = "Nutton, {Richard W} and Hamilton, {David F} and Hutchison, {James D} and Mitchell, {Martin J} and Simpson, {A Hamish Rw} and Maclean, {James G B}",
year = "2012",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1136/bmjopen-2012-001149",
language = "English",
volume = "2",
journal = "BMJ Open",
issn = "2044-6055",
publisher = "BMJ Publishing Group",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Variation in physical development in schoolboy rugby players

T2 - can maturity testing reduce mismatch?

AU - Nutton, Richard W

AU - Hamilton, David F

AU - Hutchison, James D

AU - Mitchell, Martin J

AU - Simpson, A Hamish Rw

AU - Maclean, James G B

PY - 2012/7

Y1 - 2012/7

N2 - OBJECTIVES: This study set out to pursue means of reducing mismatch in schoolboy rugby players. The primary objective was to determine whether application of previously reported thresholds of height and grip strength could be used to distinguish those 15-year-old boys appropriate to play under-18 school rugby from their peers. A secondary objective was to obtain normative data for height, weight and grip strength and to assess the variation within that data of current schoolboy rugby players. DESIGN: Cross-sectional cohort study. SETTING: 3 Scottish schools and 'Regional Assessment Centres' organised by the Scottish Rugby Union. PARTICIPANTS: 472 rugby playing youths aged 15 years (Regional Assessment Centres) and 382 schoolboys aged between 12 and 18 years (three schools). OUTCOME MEASURES: Height, weight and grip strength. RESULTS: 97% of 15-year-olds achieved the height and grip strength thresholds based on previous reported values. Larger mean values and wide variation of height, weight and grip strength were recorded in the schoolboy cohort. However, using the mean values of the cohort of 17-year-olds as a new threshold, only 7.7% of 15-year-olds would pass these thresholds. CONCLUSIONS: Large morphological variation was observed in schoolboy rugby players of the same age. Physical maturity tests described in earlier literature as pre-participation screening for contact sports were not applicable to current day 15-year-old rugby players. New criteria were measured and found to be better at identifying those 15-year-old players who had sufficient physical development to play senior school rugby.

AB - OBJECTIVES: This study set out to pursue means of reducing mismatch in schoolboy rugby players. The primary objective was to determine whether application of previously reported thresholds of height and grip strength could be used to distinguish those 15-year-old boys appropriate to play under-18 school rugby from their peers. A secondary objective was to obtain normative data for height, weight and grip strength and to assess the variation within that data of current schoolboy rugby players. DESIGN: Cross-sectional cohort study. SETTING: 3 Scottish schools and 'Regional Assessment Centres' organised by the Scottish Rugby Union. PARTICIPANTS: 472 rugby playing youths aged 15 years (Regional Assessment Centres) and 382 schoolboys aged between 12 and 18 years (three schools). OUTCOME MEASURES: Height, weight and grip strength. RESULTS: 97% of 15-year-olds achieved the height and grip strength thresholds based on previous reported values. Larger mean values and wide variation of height, weight and grip strength were recorded in the schoolboy cohort. However, using the mean values of the cohort of 17-year-olds as a new threshold, only 7.7% of 15-year-olds would pass these thresholds. CONCLUSIONS: Large morphological variation was observed in schoolboy rugby players of the same age. Physical maturity tests described in earlier literature as pre-participation screening for contact sports were not applicable to current day 15-year-old rugby players. New criteria were measured and found to be better at identifying those 15-year-old players who had sufficient physical development to play senior school rugby.

U2 - 10.1136/bmjopen-2012-001149

DO - 10.1136/bmjopen-2012-001149

M3 - Article

C2 - 22786947

VL - 2

JO - BMJ Open

JF - BMJ Open

SN - 2044-6055

IS - 4

M1 - e001149

ER -